Two failed evaluations in 2024, both with a London open EURUSD strategy that had made money on my own IC Markets raw account for three years. I blamed the prop firms at first. That was wrong, and it took me a while to work out why.
Failure one was the daily loss limit. On my own money I risk 0.5% per trade and accept that four or five losers in a row happens a few times a year. On a challenge with a 5% daily limit that sounds fine, but I had sized up to 1% per trade to hit the target faster. Four losers on a choppy Tuesday and a fifth that slipped on a stop, and I was done. The strategy didn't change. My risk did.
Failure two was subtler. The evaluation's trading conditions were different from my own account: the spread on EURUSD around 07:00 was wider, commission was charged differently, and my 3-pip targets took a bigger hit. My average winner shrank by roughly 0.4 pips after costs. On a strategy whose edge is maybe 0.8 pips per trade, that wiped out half the expectancy.
What I didn't do was test the strategy on the challenge's own conditions before starting. I assumed an edge travels. Edges as thin as scalping ones often don't.
The third attempt, at a different firm, I passed slowly at 0.5% risk, after first spending two weeks on their free trial logging spreads at my hours.
Why I failed two challenges with a strategy that works on IC Markets
-
LondonScalper
- Posts: 965
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Why I failed two challenges with a strategy that works on IC Markets
The 0.4 pip reduction on a 0.8 pip edge is the clearest example of this I've seen written down. I had something similar, and the cause was partly the commission. My own account charged per round turn, and the evaluation account had it built into a wider spread, which affected my small targets far more.
One thing I'd add to your free trial approach: log the time stamps of fills, not just the spread. On my second attempt, the evaluation server confirmed orders noticeably slower at 08:00 than my own broker, and that showed up as worse slippage on stops.
On the daily limit failure, the maths is worth spelling out. At 1% risk, five losers is 5% before slippage.
Any slip on the fifth and you're over. At 0.5%, you'd need ten losers in a row.
I'd also check whether the daily limit is calculated from the start of day balance or from equity including open trades. That changes how close a choppy morning really gets you.
Did the third firm's conditions turn out close to your own account, or did you adjust the targets to fit?
One thing I'd add to your free trial approach: log the time stamps of fills, not just the spread. On my second attempt, the evaluation server confirmed orders noticeably slower at 08:00 than my own broker, and that showed up as worse slippage on stops.
On the daily limit failure, the maths is worth spelling out. At 1% risk, five losers is 5% before slippage.
Any slip on the fifth and you're over. At 0.5%, you'd need ten losers in a row.
I'd also check whether the daily limit is calculated from the start of day balance or from equity including open trades. That changes how close a choppy morning really gets you.
Did the third firm's conditions turn out close to your own account, or did you adjust the targets to fit?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Why I failed two challenges with a strategy that works on IC Markets
Something else worth testing on the trial is the firm's news rule. Many evaluations ban opening or closing trades within a couple of minutes of high impact releases, and a London open EURUSD strategy runs straight into UK data at 07:00 and some euro area numbers around 08:00 to 09:00.
On my own broker that window is just a spread warning. On one evaluation it meant the profit on a scalp closed at target inside the window was removed, and in my log that touched roughly one morning in six.
I'd also check the minimum stop distance on the trial account. Some evaluation accounts set larger minimums, and a 3 pip target with a 4 pip stop may not even be allowed that close to price.
I'd be curious whether your win rate changed between accounts, or only the size of the wins. If the win rate dropped too, it points to fills rather than just costs.
Did you keep the same entry rules on the third attempt, or change anything apart from risk? If it was risk alone, that says a lot about how much of the first two failures was sizing.
On my own broker that window is just a spread warning. On one evaluation it meant the profit on a scalp closed at target inside the window was removed, and in my log that touched roughly one morning in six.
I'd also check the minimum stop distance on the trial account. Some evaluation accounts set larger minimums, and a 3 pip target with a 4 pip stop may not even be allowed that close to price.
I'd be curious whether your win rate changed between accounts, or only the size of the wins. If the win rate dropped too, it points to fills rather than just costs.
Did you keep the same entry rules on the third attempt, or change anything apart from risk? If it was risk alone, that says a lot about how much of the first two failures was sizing.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Why I failed two challenges with a strategy that works on IC Markets
A failed breakout occurs when price breaks a level, attracts breakout buyers, then reverses and closes back inside the range. Those trapped traders must exit, adding fuel to the reversal.
Trading failed breakouts, sometimes called fading the break, appeals because the stop is logical: just beyond the extreme of the failed break. If price goes beyond that, the trap theory is wrong. The reward can be large, since the reversal often runs back to the other side of the range.
The challenge is identifying a failure in real time. A break might hold, reverse partway, then continue. Waiting for a close back inside the range reduces false signals but sacrifices part of the move.
A rule like "enter when price closes back inside the range within three candles of the break" can be tested. Variations include requiring a minimum overshoot, a volume surge on the break, or a return to the range on stronger volume.
Results tend to vary by market regime. Failed breakouts are more common in ranging, low-volatility conditions. In strongly trending markets, breaks usually hold.
A bonus check: look at the size of the failed break. A tiny poke, one or two pips beyond the level, is usually less meaningful than a decisive overshoot of five or ten pips followed by a sharp reversal. The latter implies more trapped participants and more fuel for the reversal.
What rule defines a failed breakout, and how does the hit rate vary between ranging and trending days?
Trading failed breakouts, sometimes called fading the break, appeals because the stop is logical: just beyond the extreme of the failed break. If price goes beyond that, the trap theory is wrong. The reward can be large, since the reversal often runs back to the other side of the range.
The challenge is identifying a failure in real time. A break might hold, reverse partway, then continue. Waiting for a close back inside the range reduces false signals but sacrifices part of the move.
A rule like "enter when price closes back inside the range within three candles of the break" can be tested. Variations include requiring a minimum overshoot, a volume surge on the break, or a return to the range on stronger volume.
Results tend to vary by market regime. Failed breakouts are more common in ranging, low-volatility conditions. In strongly trending markets, breaks usually hold.
A bonus check: look at the size of the failed break. A tiny poke, one or two pips beyond the level, is usually less meaningful than a decisive overshoot of five or ten pips followed by a sharp reversal. The latter implies more trapped participants and more fuel for the reversal.
What rule defines a failed breakout, and how does the hit rate vary between ranging and trending days?