Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Partial profits mean closing part of a position at one target and letting the rest run. Many traders find it comfortable. The question is what it does to your numbers.
Suppose you risk 1R with a target of 3R. If you close half at 1.5R and the rest at 3R, your average win is 2.25R. If price reaches 1.5R and then reverses to your stop, you still make 0.75R on the half you banked, minus 0.5R lost on the rest, a net of 0.25R instead of a full loss.
The benefit is a smoother equity curve and less stress. The cost is a lower average win on trades that go all the way, which reduces the maximum payoff.
Whether it improves results depends on how often trades reach the first target and how many continue afterward. In a strategy where trades commonly reach the first level but rarely the second, partials help. In one where winners often run far, they cut the best trades short.
There is also a psychological point. A trader who feels secure after banking profit may hold the remainder through noise more calmly.
Costs matter too. Closing half a position means paying an extra spread.
Practical step: calculate your expectancy from your journal both with and without partial exits to see which number is higher.
Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
It’s Fairman 
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Worked numbers. Risk 1R, target 3R. Close half at 1R and let the rest run to 3R. If both hit, you make 0.5 plus 1.5, which is 2R instead of 3R. If price tags 1R, turns and stops you out on the rest, you make 0.5 minus 0.5, so zero instead of minus 1. You're trading upside for smoothness. Whether that's worth it depends on how often your trades reach 1R and then fail. If your journal shows that happens a lot, partials help. If most trades that reach 1R go on to hit the full target, partials cost you money over time. Run both versions on your last fifty trades and compare the totals.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Whether partials help depends on your win rate and how often trades tag 1R and then turn back. Check your journal. If many trades hit 1R and come back, partials help. If most hit full target, they cost you. You need MFE data for this, the furthest each trade went in your favour before closing. Sort the trades into three groups: never reached 1R, reached 1R but not target, reached target. If the middle group is large, partials at 1R add real value. If it's small, you're giving away half of most winners for very little protection.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
One more angle that doesn't show up in the maths: partials can make it easier to hold the runner. If banking half calms you down enough to let the rest reach target instead of panicking out, that behavioural benefit might be worth more than the theoretical cost. Compare your actual results, not just the theory. If before partials you were closing full positions early at 1.2R on average, and with partials the runner reaches 3R regularly, you're better off with partials even if the spreadsheet says full targets are optimal. The best plan is the one you'll actually follow.
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
The partial-profit maths is explained clearly. A test readers can do: recalculate their last 50 trades with and without a partial at 1.5R, and compare total R and maximum drawdown.
If the partial reduces total R only slightly but lowers drawdown noticeably, it may be worth keeping for psychological reasons. If it cuts total R a lot, the runner is where the edge lives.
If the partial reduces total R only slightly but lowers drawdown noticeably, it may be worth keeping for psychological reasons. If it cuts total R a lot, the runner is where the edge lives.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Fairman's reversal case assumes the runner goes all the way back to the original stop. Most people I know who take a partial also move the stop to breakeven at that point, and that changes the numbers more than the partial itself.
With half banked at 1.5R and the rest stopped at entry, the reversal nets 0.75R instead of 0.25R. The catch is that breakeven stops get tagged by ordinary noise, so some trades that would have reached 3R end at 0.75R too.
I ran FXS Prop Desk's test on my last 50 EURUSD trades, rounding the groups slightly and keeping the original stop. Twenty never reached 1.5R, twelve reached it and reversed, and eighteen went to 3R, so full targets gave 22R and the partial version gave 23.5R before costs.
On a scalp the extra close is not free. My round trip is about 0.05R per close, and paying it on the 30 trades that reached the first level took away 1.5R, which left the two versions level at 22R.
So for me the decision really does come down to Fairman's last post and which version I actually hold properly. Has anyone measured how often their breakeven stop gets hit before the runner would have reached target?
With half banked at 1.5R and the rest stopped at entry, the reversal nets 0.75R instead of 0.25R. The catch is that breakeven stops get tagged by ordinary noise, so some trades that would have reached 3R end at 0.75R too.
I ran FXS Prop Desk's test on my last 50 EURUSD trades, rounding the groups slightly and keeping the original stop. Twenty never reached 1.5R, twelve reached it and reversed, and eighteen went to 3R, so full targets gave 22R and the partial version gave 23.5R before costs.
On a scalp the extra close is not free. My round trip is about 0.05R per close, and paying it on the 30 trades that reached the first level took away 1.5R, which left the two versions level at 22R.
So for me the decision really does come down to Fairman's last post and which version I actually hold properly. Has anyone measured how often their breakeven stop gets hit before the runner would have reached target?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
I went back and answered my own breakeven question on the same 50 EURUSD trades. Of the 18 that reached 3R, five came back to within a pip of entry first, so a breakeven stop at 1.5R would have zeroed each of those runners.
That costs 1.5R per trade on the runner half, 7.5R in total. Against it, the 12 reversals would each have saved 0.5R on the runner, which is 6R, so moving to breakeven at the first target lost me 1.5R over the sample.
Small numbers, but the direction surprised me, because breakeven always feels like the safe choice. The trades that dip back to entry are often the clean ones that retest the breakout level before going.
What I am testing now is leaving the runner's stop alone until price has covered 2R, and only then moving it to entry. On these 50 trades that comes out level with never moving the stop at all, which tells me the breakeven move adds comfort rather than R.
One caveat is the spread at the moment of the dip. A runner stopped at exactly entry still pays the round trip, so on a scalp breakeven is really minus 0.05R, and a stop one pip beyond entry changes the count again.
That costs 1.5R per trade on the runner half, 7.5R in total. Against it, the 12 reversals would each have saved 0.5R on the runner, which is 6R, so moving to breakeven at the first target lost me 1.5R over the sample.
Small numbers, but the direction surprised me, because breakeven always feels like the safe choice. The trades that dip back to entry are often the clean ones that retest the breakout level before going.
What I am testing now is leaving the runner's stop alone until price has covered 2R, and only then moving it to entry. On these 50 trades that comes out level with never moving the stop at all, which tells me the breakeven move adds comfort rather than R.
One caveat is the spread at the moment of the dip. A runner stopped at exactly entry still pays the round trip, so on a scalp breakeven is really minus 0.05R, and a stop one pip beyond entry changes the count again.
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Taking Partial Profits: The Math Behind Selling Half
Taking partial profit, such as closing half a position at the first target and letting the rest run, is popular because it feels balanced. Its mathematical effect, however, is often misunderstood.
Partial exits reduce variance by locking in a portion of gains, but they also reduce average profit when the remaining position would have hit a larger target. Whether the trade-off helps depends on the distribution of price movement after the first target. In trending conditions, running the full position produces more. In ranging conditions, locking in early gains avoids reversals.
Testing both approaches on the same data, with costs included, shows which performs better for a specific strategy. Equity curve smoothness and drawdown also matter, since some traders value reduced volatility. The extra order incurs an additional spread and commission, which is a real cost for scalpers. Without testing, partial exits can become a habit that feels safe while quietly reducing expectancy.
Partial exits reduce variance by locking in a portion of gains, but they also reduce average profit when the remaining position would have hit a larger target. Whether the trade-off helps depends on the distribution of price movement after the first target. In trending conditions, running the full position produces more. In ranging conditions, locking in early gains avoids reversals.
Testing both approaches on the same data, with costs included, shows which performs better for a specific strategy. Equity curve smoothness and drawdown also matter, since some traders value reduced volatility. The extra order incurs an additional spread and commission, which is a real cost for scalpers. Without testing, partial exits can become a habit that feels safe while quietly reducing expectancy.