Consensus Forecasts and Surprise Indexes: Measuring What Was Not Expected

[Fairman]

Consensus Forecasts and Surprise Indexes: Measuring What Was Not Expected

Markets move on surprises, not on levels. Two tools help measure them.

The first is the consensus forecast for each data release, typically an average or median of analyst estimates collected by data providers and shown on economic calendars. Comparing the actual figure with consensus gives the surprise. A reading above consensus is positive for the economy's outlook, and usually for its currency, though the reaction also depends on policy implications.

The second is a surprise index, which aggregates many data surprises into a single measure for an economy. Citigroup's surprise indexes are a well-known example. A positive reading means data have been coming in better than expected on balance, and a negative reading means worse.

These indexes tend to mean-revert, since analysts adjust their forecasts after repeated misses. Persistent positive surprises lead to higher expectations, which makes further positive surprises harder.

For traders, the information is useful for context. A currency whose economy has been surprising to the upside may have momentum, until expectations catch up. A sharp turn in the index can mark a change in the data cycle.

Be careful with interpretation. Consensus figures can be stale, and revisions matter.

Use surprise data alongside rate expectations and technical context, not as a standalone signal.

Practical step: for the next three releases, record the consensus, the actual figure, and the price reaction.

[Fairman]

The mean reversion point is subtle and useful. After a long run of positive surprises, forecasters catch up, and the next releases have a harder bar to beat. That's why the surprise index tends to swing above and below zero rather than staying high. For trading, it means a currency whose economy has been beating forecasts for months isn't necessarily set for more upside surprises. The positive news may already be priced in, with forecasts raised to match. Some traders watch for a surprise index turning down from a high level as an early warning that the data run is fading, before the currency itself has reacted.

[Fairman]

Recording consensus, actual and reaction for a few releases is a nice way to learn how much surprise your pair actually needs to move. Take US CPI for example. Note the consensus, the actual, the surprise in tenths of a percent, and how many pips EURUSD moved in the first 15 minutes after 1:30pm Lagos. After six or eight releases you'll see that a 0.1 percent miss on core CPI often moves the pair a lot more than a similar miss on headline. You'll also see that some releases get completely ignored because something bigger is dominating, like a Fed meeting the following week. That kind of note is useful for planning.