Advertisement IC Markets

New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Post by LondonScalper »

New member onboarding: costs first, strategies second

If I ran onboarding for this forum I would ban strategy hopping for the first fortnight. New members need a cost and risk spine before another entry-pattern clone. Without that spine, every new thread becomes another way to avoid measuring the bill.

Proposed path:
  • Week 1: journal costs, daily loss limit, news blackout — no new strategy threads required.
  • Week 2: one session playbook, tiny size, process score at end of day.
  • Only then: refine entries and compare setups after costs.
Edge without cost literacy is cosplay. The kindest thing we can do for new scalpers is make the boring modules mandatory before the exciting ones.

Would you support a costs-first onboarding path for new members — and what module would you put on day one?

Mentors who jump straight to entries are often selling excitement. A costs-first path is slower content and better survivors — which is what a scalping forum should optimise for.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Post by PropScalpDesk »

I'd support it. For day one, I'd pick one exercise: work out what a single round trip costs on your own broker, with your own lot size, in your account currency. That means spread at the time you actually trade, plus commission both ways, and then that figure as a share of your usual stop.

Most new members have never done it, and the first time you see that a 5-pip-stop scalp gives up 15 to 20% of the risk before the market moves, a lot of the strategy threads read differently. A simple shared spreadsheet template would make it a ten-minute task.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Post by Shadow Trader »

I would back it, and PropScalpDesk's exercise is the right first module. One change I would make is doing the sum twice, once for the hour you plan to trade and once for the hour you actually end up trading.

Plenty of new members say they trade London and then click late in the Asian session because that is when they are free. On EURUSD that difference alone can turn a manageable cost into a large one.
img_12574_r1.png
img_12574_r1.png (54.74 KiB) Viewed 113 times
The chart uses my own rough figures, about 0.9 pips all-in during London and 1.4 in late Asia. On a 5 pip stop that is 18 percent against 28 percent, and on a 3 pip stop the Asia version gives up close to half the risk before price moves.

The second module I would add is multiplying by trade count. Eight trades a day at 0.18R of cost each is about 1.4R a day spent before any edge shows up, which tends to end the overtrading conversation quickly.

For the template, a column for the time of each fill would help. Most people only notice the spread problem once they see their own timestamps next to it.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Post by Shadow Trader »

If there is room for a module before costs, I would put position sizing there. Working out a round trip as a share of the stop only means something once the lot size behind it is right, and that is where most new traders I have helped went wrong.

The usual mistake is pip value on anything outside the dollar majors. A 0.01 lot on EURUSD is about 10 cents a pip, but a 0.01 lot of gold gains or loses one dollar for each dollar of price movement, and people who carry their forex pip habit across can end up far bigger than they meant to be.

So my first exercise would be three sizes worked out by hand, one each for EURUSD, USDJPY and XAUUSD, all risking the same half percent. The broker's own calculator can check the answers afterwards, not before.

On the fortnight without strategy hopping, I would make it a trade count instead of a date. Twenty trades on one playbook teach more than two weeks in which a new member only trades three times.

Would the template PropScalpDesk mentioned have room for a sizing tab? That way the day one task covers both sums at once.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: New member onboarding path: costs first strategies second

Post by Shadow Trader »

Most traders watch the chart during news. A smaller group watches the sequence of events before the chart moves.

First, spreads widen, often 30 to 60 seconds before the release. Liquidity providers pull back, and the book thins. Second, price tends to drift sideways or tighten, a compression that reflects waiting. Third, the release hits, and the first move is frequently a spike that reverses within a minute. The real direction often takes several minutes to establish.

The first spike catches stops on both sides. Traders who entered right on the number are often on the wrong side of the second move.

An approach used by some scalpers is to ignore the first 90 seconds entirely and wait for the market to show its hand. It gives up the first move, which is the most dangerous, and keeps the second, which is usually cleaner.

Is there a standard waiting period after releases for people here, or does it vary by event?
Post Reply