Advertisement IC Markets

Session journal tags: setup quality by time of day

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Session journal tags: setup quality by time of day

Post by LondonScalper »

Session tags vs setup tags

I used to tag every scalp by setup name only. Useful, until I noticed the same “A+ pullback” was a gift at London open and rubbish after 16:00 London. The edge was not the pattern — it was when I took it.

So I split the journal:
  • Setup quality (A / B / C against written rules)
  • Time-of-day bucket (pre-London, London drive, overlap, late NY)
  • Optional: pair + spread band at entry
After a few hundred rows, one chart told the story: B setups in the first 90 minutes of London still beat A setups in thin late NY. That changed my session budget more than any new indicator.

Questions for the desk:
  • Do you score setup quality separately from session quality?
  • How many buckets before the tags become noise?
  • Anyone correlating tag quality with cost of carry/spread by hour?
Happy to share a blank tag list if useful — keep it boring, that is the point.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Session journal tags: setup quality by time of day

Post by Shadow Trader »

B setups in the first 90 minutes beating A setups in late NY matches my data almost exactly. I'd go further: an A setup after 16:00 London is close to break even after costs for me, which makes the A grade misleading at that hour.

On the number of buckets, I settled on four as well, and tried six for a quarter. Six left under 30 trades in some buckets, too few to say anything, so I went back.

I'd make spread band at entry required rather than optional. In my journal spread explains part of what looks like a time-of-day effect. The late NY trades weren't only worse setups, they were paying about 0.3 pips more on average.

Have you checked whether your grading drifts by session too? I found I was grading more trades as A late in the day, probably because I wanted them to be.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Session journal tags: setup quality by time of day

Post by Shadow Trader »

LondonScalper asked about cost by hour, and that is the column that finally stopped me overrating late NY A grades. Once I logged all in spread plus commission next to the session bucket, the late A setups were not just weaker, they were more expensive by about 0.25 to 0.4 pips.

I now refuse an A grade if the entry spread is above my London median for that pair. The grade still goes in the sheet, but the trade is tagged SKIP COST and does not count toward the A win rate.

Four buckets stay. Pair plus spread band is required, and I dropped the optional direction tag because it never changed a decision.

The grading drift you flagged is real on my side too. After 15:00 I force a second look at the written rules before I type A, and about one in five gets bumped down to B.

Have you tried scoring the same trade twice, once live and once on Sunday review? The gap between those two grades taught me more than any new bucket.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Session journal tags: setup quality by time of day

Post by Shadow Trader »

Because scalping revolves around many small opportunities, a tempting belief says that profit rises in step with the number of trades taken. If a setup has a positive expectancy, the reasoning goes, then more repetitions must yield more money. The logic holds only when every additional trade has the same quality as the best ones.

In practice, setups are not evenly spread through the day. The cleanest conditions, such as tight spreads, active liquidity and a clear structure, appear in certain windows. Trades taken outside them tend to carry weaker odds and higher costs. Adding such trades can dilute the average expectancy instead of increasing total profit.

Costs scale linearly with trade count. Each entry pays the spread and possibly a commission, so a strategy with a small edge per trade can see most of its gain disappear as volume rises. Mental energy is also finite, and attention tends to slip after a long run of decisions, which leads to errors that would not occur earlier in the session.

A better measure than trade count is expectancy per trade after all costs, together with the quality of the conditions in which trades occur. Taking fewer, cleaner opportunities often produces the same result with less strain. Activity feels productive, but only profitable activity counts.
Post Reply