Advertisement IC Markets

Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Post by LondonScalper »

Not all FVG fills are equal on EURUSD.

Full fills into the opposite side of an imbalance often arrive late for a scalp — you have already paid the journey and the leftover edge is thin. Partial fills (roughly into the imbalance, with rejection) have been more useful for me as continuation or reclaim entries, especially in the London first hour when location matters more than completing the cartoon rectangle.

Rule: I do not hold for "the rest of the gap" as a thesis. If the partial fill gives me a structured reaction, I manage it as a normal scalp with normal invalidation. If price slices through to a full fill with acceptance, the idea is wrong — I exit without debating whether the gap "owes" me a bounce later.

This is the depth question sitting beside broader FVG fill discussions.
  • Partial or full fill — what does your EURUSD sample say?
  • Do you measure fill depth, or is it visual?
Complement to fill-the-gap folklore — specifically how deep is enough.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Post by PropScalpDesk »

I measure depth, because visually I always talked myself into "close enough". I tag each fill at 25, 50, 75 or 100% of the gap, taken from wick to wick on the three-candle pattern, and note whether the reaction bar closed back outside.

Two filters that removed most of the rubbish for me. First, a minimum gap size relative to spread. On EURUSD M1 plenty of "imbalances" measure somewhere between 0.3 and 0.5 pips, which is barely more than the raw spread plus commission, so there's nothing to trade inside them; I ignore anything under roughly three times my all-in cost. Second, the gap has to come from displacement away from a level I had marked before the session, not just any fast candle.

Is your partial-fill sample mostly from the London first hour, or spread through the morning?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Post by Shadow Trader »

Mine is mostly the first hour, and that turns out to matter. Of 64 EURUSD M1 fills that passed both of PropScalpDesk's filters, 41 came between 08:00 and 09:00 London, with the rest spread through the morning.

I tag depth the same way, at 25, 50, 75 and 100 percent from wick to wick. Counting a reaction as a close back outside the gap on the next bar, I got 9 of 16 at 25 percent, 11 of 20 at 50, 6 of 15 at 75 and 3 of 13 at a full fill.
img_12465_r1.png
img_12465_r1.png (54.11 KiB) Viewed 104 times
The chart puts those four buckets side by side, and the drop after the halfway point is what supports LondonScalper's view. A full fill reacting 3 times in 13 is about what I would expect from a level that is no longer there.

Splitting by time made the halfway bucket less impressive. In the first hour it reacted on 9 of 14, but after 09:00 only on 2 of 6, which is too few to trust but points the same way as LondonScalper's comment about location.

For the minimum gap I use 1.5 pips on EURUSD, roughly three times a 0.5 all in cost. That alone removed about half the gaps I used to tag.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Post by Shadow Trader »

Another split I ran on the same 64 fills was the age of the gap. A first return to an untouched gap reacted 25 times out of 47, while a gap being visited for the second or third time reacted on only 4 of 17.

That second number is close to the full fill result. Once price has traded into the imbalance, the orders that left it there have been partly filled, and the gap is a drawing more than a level.

Stop placement is where the partial fill idea gets awkward on small gaps. If I enter at 50 percent of a 1.5 pip gap and put the stop beyond the far edge with a 0.5 pip buffer, the risk is 1.25 pips, nearly the size of the gap.

So for gaps under about 3 pips I enter at the near edge with a limit and accept that some fills only touch 25 percent. Above 3 pips the 50 percent entry gives a sensible stop and target on EURUSD M1.

LondonScalper, when you say a full fill with acceptance, how many closes do you need beyond the far edge? I use two M1 closes, but on fast mornings one close has already been enough to cost me.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Partial FVG fill vs full fill: which I treat as scalp edge on EURUSD

Post by Shadow Trader »

When an order is larger than the liquidity available at the quoted price, the platform needs a rule for what happens to the remainder. That rule is the fill policy, and it changes real outcomes.

Fill or Kill requires the whole volume to execute at once or not at all. It protects against fragmented positions but can produce rejections in thin conditions. Immediate or Cancel fills whatever volume is available immediately and cancels the rest, so partial positions are possible. Return, offered on some platforms and instruments, leaves unfilled volume working in the book as a pending order, which can lead to fills later at a different level.

Supported policies depend on the broker, the symbol, and the execution mode. Automated systems that assume a full fill can end up with mismatched stop and take-profit sizes when only part of an order executes. Code and manual routines alike benefit from checking the actual filled volume, and from reading the symbol specification for the allowed filling modes before sending orders.

Retail sizes rarely exhaust deep major pairs, yet partial fills do appear during news spikes and on less liquid crosses or metals.
Post Reply