Advertisement IC Markets

EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Post by LondonScalper »

EURGBP can print a clean impulse then a tidy pullback — and still not pay you after costs.

I define impulse as a decisive displacement away from a level, not three overlapping M5 bars that merely lean. Pullback entry is a pause or micro-structure hold, not a deep retrace into the whole move. Targets are modest on a cross; that is precisely why the cost conversation matters more than on EURUSD.

Rule: if projected reward after typical spread is under roughly 1R net, I skip even when the pattern is textbook. I would rather miss EURGBP than collect scratches that feel like wins on the chart and losses in the account. London is preferred; overlap only if the impulse is unfinished and spreads behave.

I also avoid stacking EURGBP with a large EURUSD idea the same hour — correlated ego, not diversification.
  • Is impulse–pullback still viable on EURGBP for you after costs?
  • Do you wait for London only, or trade it in the overlap too?
Honest numbers welcome — screenshots of pretty pullbacks less so.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Post by PropScalpDesk »

Numbers on my side: on a raw account EURGBP has cost me about 0.5 to 0.8 pips spread at the London open plus roughly half a pip in commission per round trip, so call it 1.2 pips all-in. With a 5-pip stop, that's about a quarter of R gone before anything happens. Your 1R-net rule then needs a gross target of at least 6 pips on a pair whose whole-day range is often only 30 to 40.

That's why I only take it in the first hour of London and skip the overlap. Later in the day there usually isn't enough range left to reach the target, however clean the pullback looks.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

PropScalpDesk's 1.2 pips all in is close to what I pay, so turn it into a break even number first. With a 5 pip stop and a 6 pip target, a winner nets 4.8 and a loser costs 6.2, so you need to be right about 56 percent of the time just to stand still.

That is a high bar for a pullback entry on a cross that spends most of the day rotating. My own EURGBP pullback tests never cleared that line once costs were in.

What helped me was making the trade bigger in pips rather than taking more of them. With an 8 pip stop and a 12 pip target the cost drops to about 15 percent of risk, and the break even rate falls to roughly 46 percent.

The catch is that a 12 pip move on EURGBP needs a real driver, which usually means UK data at 07:00 London or a fresh euro headline. On a day with nothing scheduled the first hour rarely leaves that much clean room after the impulse, so I simply sit out.

LondonScalper, how do you measure the impulse itself? I compare the M5 bar range with its 20 bar average and want at least double, which filters out the leaning candles you described.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

One cost that does not show in the 1R net rule is the scratch. Move a EURGBP stop to the entry price and the trade still loses the full 1.2 pips all in when it gets tagged, which on a 5 pip stop is about a quarter of R each time.

That adds up quickly on a pair that rotates. In one quarter where a third of my roughly 60 trades ended at so called breakeven, those scratches alone cost close to 5R.

So I either leave the stop alone or move it to entry plus costs, never to the entry price itself. With 1.2 pips of cost that means entry plus 1.5, and only once price has moved at least 4 pips in my favour.

The second habit is skipping the first few minutes of London. Spreads at 08:00 sit near the top of PropScalpDesk's range, while by 08:15 they have usually settled toward the lower end, and on a cross with this little room that difference is worth waiting for.

LondonScalper, do you count scratches as losses when you review the pair? Mine looked much better on the trade log than in the account until I started doing that.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURGBP and the impulse pullback: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Some brokers don't offer every cross. But any cross can be approximated by trading two pairs. A trader wanting EURGBP could buy EURUSD and sell GBPUSD in matching amounts, producing a similar exposure.

The idea is neat, and it carries costs. Two spreads instead of one. Two commissions. Two sets of slippage. The resulting position also drifts out of balance as the rates change, because the dollar value of each leg shifts.

For scalpers, the extra cost is usually fatal. A strategy aiming for 3 pips on EURGBP loses a big chunk of it to the doubled friction.

Where synthetic crosses do help is in analysis. Charting EURUSD divided by GBPUSD gives a clean view of EURGBP even when the broker's own feed is thin or unavailable. Comparing the synthetic price with the quoted one occasionally reveals feed quirks.

Does the broker price the crosses directly, or derive them from the majors, and how close do they track?
Post Reply