Advertisement IC Markets

IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Post by LondonScalper »

IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes from my log -- not a promo.

I am not here to crown a winner. I am sharing fields I compare when cable costs matter: median spread at London open, slippage on market orders around 08:00-09:00, reject rate, and commission structure into round-trip points at my usual size.

Method
Same week type if possible, same VPS story, same order types. Marketing screenshots do not count. I want a week of my clicks. On quiet days differences shrink; on news days they scream.

Switching costs (templates, hotkeys, psychological familiarity) belong in the decision. Cheapest average spread loses if rejects cluster when I actually trade.

What metrics decided your last GBPUSD venue choice -- if you compared at all?

Post numbers if you share: sample size, session, and account type. Without those, comparison threads become marketing by accident. I will gladly update my own sheet when someone provides honest clicks -- not referral poetry.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Post by PropScalpDesk »

GBPUSD cost notes, not a broker crown

Comparing IC versus Exness on cable is useful when fields are boring and consistent: median spread at London open, slippage on market orders in the first hour, reject rate, commission into round-trip points at your size. Crowning a winner from one anecdote helps nobody.

From Frankfurt I want same-week-type samples and my own deal history. Marketing pages do not sit in my sheet. If fills degrade around UK data, that belongs in the scorecard with timestamps.

Rule: switch venues only after a documented sample, not after one bad morning and anger.

I re-run the comparison after any account-type or liquidity-provider change. Yesterday’s winner can become today’s expensive habit without a headline.

I ignore affiliate leaderboards and screenshots without timestamps. My deal history is the only ranking that pays my rent.

Cost and fill notes are maintenance, not a one-time blog post.

Which field has moved your ranking most lately — open spread, or slippage distribution on market orders?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Post by Shadow Trader »

The comparison only became fair for me when I ran both accounts at the same time. Same signal, both tickets sent within a second of each other, for about 40 paired trades over three weeks of London opens.

Doing it in separate weeks lets the market pick the result. A quiet week on one account and a UK CPI week on the other will produce a winner that says nothing about the venue.

On cost, I convert everything to pips at my size before comparing. On GBPUSD a 7 dollar round trip commission per lot is 0.7 pips, so a raw spread of 0.3 plus commission comes to about 1.0, which is roughly where many standard accounts sit with no commission.

To answer the question, slippage distribution moved my ranking more than spread did. The medians were within 0.1 pip of each other, but the worst 10 percent of fills differed by close to half a pip, and nearly all of those were filled between 08:00 and 08:10.

I also split positive and negative slippage. One account passed on some favourable fills and the other almost never did, and an average hides that completely.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Post by Shadow Trader »

A flaw in my paired test that I only found afterwards was the order the tickets went out. My script always sent to the same account first, so the second order reached its server around 200 milliseconds later, and on a fast 08:00 candle that delay alone is worth a fraction of a pip.

I now alternate which account goes first on each signal. Rerunning with that change and extending the sample to 90 pairs, the gap in the worst 10 percent of fills shrank to about 0.3 pip.

That is still a real difference, but it shows how small samples flatter the tail. With 40 pairs the worst 10 percent is only four trades, and one bad minute can produce the whole effect.

Swap is the field I left out entirely. Most of my cable scalps close within the hour so it rarely matters, but on the odd trade held past 22:00 London the two accounts charged noticeably different amounts, and the Wednesday triple swap makes it worth a line in the scorecard.

For anyone copying the method, record the execution time each platform reports as well as the price. It separates slippage caused by the market moving from slippage caused by a slow route.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: IC Markets vs Exness on GBPUSD: cost and fill notes

Post by Shadow Trader »

Some traders try to replicate or hedge a cross pair by trading its components. For example, selling EURUSD and buying GBPUSD to approximate a short EURGBP. It looks neat on paper, and it often disappoints in practice.

The first issue is cost. Two trades mean two spreads, two commissions, and two chances for slippage. The cost of the synthetic position can be much higher than the cost of trading the cross directly.

The second is mismatch. Pip values differ between the legs, so equal lot sizes do not produce equal exposure. Position sizing has to be adjusted, and rounding on small accounts makes that imprecise.

The third is timing. If the two orders do not fill at exactly the same moment, a small difference in entry creates an unintended directional bet.

Synthetic crosses can make sense when the cross itself has poor liquidity or high spreads. In most other cases, the direct pair is the cleaner choice.

Has building a cross from its legs ever saved you money, or did the extra costs outweigh the benefit?
Post Reply