Advertisement IC Markets

Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
PTScalper
Site Admin
Posts: 7821
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2026 1:28 pm

Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by PTScalper »

Hi traders/scalpers,

i decided to share some of my ideas about forex scalping, because i understand, that most of you,
who tried that actually lost their hard made money.

So based on that i found out at lot of forex forums, that lot of traders actually think, that it is not legit trading strategy or
the call it as scam.

From my perspective it is not scam, it is possible to make money by that, but on another hand i understand, that it is not so easy
and it is not for every body.

I have traded forex spot market for more than 18 years, i lost more than 30 accounts, in worst time ever i lost 10 accounts in row ..
But it is best what could happen to me .. Why? because only once your loose, you will use your brain at best possible level, wins will not teach
you anything.
I love forex scalping, because it suits to me the best. It is fast, most of the time i do not have to hold positions over night and in good days, im
able to make very nice returns. But it is not easy as well. You have to be prepared for higher level of stress. Some days you will make like 100+ positions.

What is really important is to be prepared for that and give it try ;-)

At beginning my main tip for you, use proper money management.
My contains mainly 4 steps:

1) Deposit part of my own money.
2) Risk it small.
3) Once you will make at least some profit, withdraw it.
4) Scale it just from profit and in my mind you will be risk free :-)

Take a care and have a good forex scalping trading sessions ;-)
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by LondonScalper »

PTScalper wrote:lot of traders actually think, that it is not legit trading strategy or the call it as scam... i lost more than 30 accounts
Scalping isn’t a scam. Plenty of marketing around scalping is.

It’s a cost-sensitive, process-heavy way to harvest small moves. People lose accounts because of leverage, no daily stop, toxic execution, or trading every M1 wiggle like it owes them rent — not because the market secretly forbids short holds. Your point about losses teaching more than wins is rough but fair; I’d only add that the lesson has to be written into rules, or you just repurchase the same lesson.

What makes it viable in practice:
  • Pairs/sessions where all-in cost fits the target
  • Hard loss limits
  • Selectivity over ticket count theatre
Possible? Yes. Easy? No. Suitable for everyone? Absolutely not. If someone can’t watch a screen with discipline or measure their costs, they’re better on a slower style.

What was the common failure mode across those early accounts — size, session, or sticking to losers?
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by PropScalpDesk »

Not a scam — often just unpaid labour

Scalping is not inherently a scam. It is a high-friction job: costs, discipline, session selection, and emotional control under time pressure. Many people lose because those frictions were ignored, then call the style fake. That conclusion is understandable and still incomplete.

From full-time experience out of Frankfurt: it is possible, but only if expectancy survives real spreads and you stop when the daily limit says stop. Marketing that promises easy minutes-to-riches is the scammy part; market microstructure is not. I treat it like skilled shift work — prepare, execute, shut down. No romance, no overnight personality change after one green open.

If your losses cluster around news, wide spreads, or days without a written stop, the style is not the scam — the missing operations are. Fix the job description before you abandon the chart style entirely.

What made you ask the question — personal results, broker behaviour that felt predatory, or content that oversold the lifestyle?
LondonNewsTrader
Posts: 421
Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2026 9:30 am

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by LondonNewsTrader »

PTScalper wrote: Some days you will make like 100+ positions.
At that kind of frequency the cost side decides almost everything, which is probably why so many people conclude scalping is a scam. A hundred trades at even half a pip of extra cost each is 50 pips a day lost to friction before skill comes into it. Most of that excess comes from a few windows, the rollover hour and the minutes around big releases, when spreads are widest.

For anyone trying high-frequency manual scalping, I'd suggest marking those windows as no-trade from day one. It removes a large share of the expensive trades without touching the strategy itself.
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1693
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Losing 30 accounts and still being here after 18 years says more about scalping than most "it's a scam" threads do. The method isn't the scam. The scam is usually the packaging: a signal service, a course or an EA sold as if the hard part were the entry.

Going by the journals posted on this board, the scalpers who last tend to have three things in common. They know their real cost per trade in pips, they cap the number of trades per session, and they stop for the day after a fixed loss without negotiating. None of that is exciting, which is probably why it rarely appears in the marketing.

What would you say changed between the account you lost tenth in a row and the first one you kept? Was it a rule, a size change, or something outside the charts?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Steps 3 and 4 of that money management plan are where the idea of trading risk free can backfire. Once the deposit is withdrawn, the profit left in the account is still real money, and treating it as free tends to push the size up.

Say 1,000 grows to 1,500 at 1 percent risk, so 15 dollars a trade. Withdraw the 1,000 and trade the remaining 500 at 5 percent because it feels like house money, and each trade now risks 25 dollars, more than before on a smaller balance.

Losing that 500 costs exactly as much as losing 500 of the original deposit. The money just changed labels.

The part of the plan that does work is the withdrawal itself. Pulling the deposit out locks in a result and puts a hard ceiling on what any bad run can take.

A version that keeps both is to withdraw the deposit and then keep the same percentage risk on what remains. Scaling then comes from the balance growing rather than from the percentage going up.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Step 2 of the plan, risk it small, probably explains the 10 accounts in a row better than anything else. At 100 positions a day a long losing streak is not bad luck, it is a scheduled event.

Say a scalper wins 45 percent of the time. Across 1,000 trades, about ten busy days, the chance of a run of at least 10 losses somewhere in there is roughly 68 percent. At a 50 percent win rate it is still about 39 percent.

What that streak does depends entirely on the size. With 1 percent risk per trade, ten straight losses cost about 9.6 percent of the balance. At 5 percent the same run takes about 40 percent, and at 10 percent it takes about 65 percent.
img_430_r2.png
img_430_r2.png (50.51 KiB) Viewed 176 times
The chart (illustration) shows those drawdowns side by side for 1, 2, 5 and 10 percent risk per trade. Only the first two leave an account that can still trade normally afterwards.

So the honest answer to the scam question may be that the method survives and the sizing does not. Were those 10 accounts mostly lost to one big run like this, or to a slow bleed from costs?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is forex scalping scam or it is possible to make money with it?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Scammers copy the identities of brokers, well-known traders and support staff, using stolen photos, cloned websites and fake social media profiles. Deepfake audio and video make impersonation more convincing than before.

Common patterns: a private message from a "support agent" after a public complaint, asking for login details or remote access. A "famous trader" offering to manage money for a guaranteed return. A cloned broker site with slightly altered address, collecting deposits. A video call from a "manager" requesting verification fees.

Protections: contact brokers only through official channels found by typing the address manually or using saved bookmarks. Treat unsolicited messages as hostile, especially those that follow a public post about a problem. Never share passwords, one-time codes or screen access. Verify any unusual request through a second channel, such as phoning the number on the official website.

Fees demanded to release funds are a classic red flag. Legitimate brokers deduct costs from the account, not through new payments.

Reporting impersonation to the platform and regulator helps others.

A short family or team agreement helps: for any request involving money or credentials, a call-back to a known number is mandatory, however urgent it seems. Deepfakes make voice and video less reliable proof of identity than they used to be, and a pre-agreed verification question adds a layer scammers can't guess.

Has an impersonation attempt been encountered, and what gave it away?
Post Reply