Page 1 of 1
I don't leave a GBPJPY limit sitting through the Tokyo lunch when the spread can jump from 1.8 to 3.4 pips
Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 11:11 am
by Fairman
A limit I leave working through the Tokyo lunch is sitting in a spread I no longer trust. On GBPJPY the quote can be perfectly fine at 02:00 London, then the lunch window around 02:30 to 03:30 arrives, and the spread that was 1.8 pips can jump to 3.4. A pending fill in that window is not the same fill I priced when the book was normal. I can get tagged on a spread print, or I can get a fill I would not have accepted if I had been watching the quote.

- 15-gbpjpy-tokyo-lunch-limit.png (106.22 KiB) Viewed 49 times
The schematic is a buy limit at 198.50, stop 198.10, 40 pips. At $6.45 a pip, 0.15 lot risks $38.70, inside the $40 I allow on a $10,000 account. Target 199.30, 80 pips, 2R, $77.40. That is a ticket I will send at 02:00 if the level is valid and the spread is 1.8. I cancel the limit by 02:20, before that lunch window, and I only put it back after 03:45 if 198.50 is still a POI I want. I don't leave 0.15 lot hanging while the spread is 3.4 and I am not at the desk.
If the level is that good, it can wait an hour. A lunch fill I did not supervise is not the careful 198.50 I wrote on the pad.
Re: I don't leave a GBPJPY limit sitting through the Tokyo lunch when the spread can jump from 1.8 to 3.4 pips
Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 2:08 pm
by Fairman
The extra 1.6 pips of spread, from 1.8 to 3.4, is $1.55 on 0.15 lot, which does not sound like much next to $38.70. The damage is not only the $1.55. It is the fill quality and the stop distance changing at the same time. If the bid-ask blows out, my fill at 198.50 can come on a quote that says little about where the market really traded, and a 3.4-pip spread also eats into the 40 pips of room I thought I had to 198.10, because my sell stop triggers on the bid. I would rather not be in for $1.55 of theoretical cost and a sloppy fill I cannot defend.
Re: I don't leave a GBPJPY limit sitting through the Tokyo lunch when the spread can jump from 1.8 to 3.4 pips
Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 5:10 pm
by Fairman
The rule is even tighter if I ever feel tempted to use a 16-pip, EURUSD-style stop on GBPJPY. $40 at $6.45 a pip and 16 pips is 0.38 lot, $39.22. In that case 3.4 pips is already 21 percent of the stop distance, which is a serious slice of a $40 ticket, not a rounding error. That is one more reason I use 40 pips and 0.15 lot on this pair when I trade it at all, and it is a hard reason not to leave even that ticket working through a known wide-spread window.
Re: I don't leave a GBPJPY limit sitting through the Tokyo lunch when the spread can jump from 1.8 to 3.4 pips
Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:06 pm
by Fairman
I cancel at 02:20, not at 02:31 after the first wide print has already appeared. If 198.50 trades without me during lunch, I missed it. That is allowed. I can look at 03:45, see whether the level held or failed, and decide then. What I will not do is move the limit to 198.40 at 02:25 so I can 'still catch it' if lunch spikes, because that is a new entry I did not plan, in the exact window I said I did not trust. No limit is better than a bargain limit in a 3.4-pip spread.