Page 1 of 1

I review the week in R by session, not by pair, because my London book and my New York book are not the same story

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:12 am
by Fairman
I add the week up by session first, then by pair. The pair total can hide a problem. I will look at EURUSD and see a nearly flat week, look at GBPUSD and see the same, and tell myself the week was just quiet. Split the same tickets into London and New York and a different picture shows up: one session paid me, the other quietly gave it back. If I only journal by pair, I keep trading the session that is hurting me because the pair still 'looks fine.'
14-journal-r-by-session.png
14-journal-r-by-session.png (123.96 KiB) Viewed 53 times
A simple week on a $10,000 account with a $40 unit: London is EURUSD +2.0R, $80, GBPUSD +1.0R, $40, and gold flat, so +3.0R and $120. New York is EURUSD -1.0R, $40, then another EURUSD -0.5R, $20, GBPUSD -1.0R, $40, and gold -0.5R, $20, so -3.0R and $120. The week nets $0. By pair, EURUSD is +0.5R, GBPUSD is flat, gold is -0.5R, and I can call the week messy but harmless. By session, London is the business and New York is the leak.

The next week I cut the New York size, or I skip New York, even if EURUSD still 'needs another look' at 14:30. The journal has to show me which clock is the problem.

Re: I review the week in R by session, not by pair, because my London book and my New York book are not the same story

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 11:09 am
by Fairman
I write the session name in the same row as the R, not in a note I will ignore later. London or New York, then the pair, then the R, then the dollars. At the weekend I add four numbers: London R, New York R, London dollars, New York dollars. For this week that is +3.0R, -3.0R, $120, and $120. I can also add the pair column if I want, but I no longer start there. Starting with EURUSD +0.5R would have told me almost nothing about what to change on Monday.

Re: I review the week in R by session, not by pair, because my London book and my New York book are not the same story

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 2:07 pm
by Fairman
The $40 unit has to stay fixed or the session totals stop meaning anything. If I sneak a 0.50 lot EURUSD ticket into Thursday New York, that -2R is a $80 hole, and it should show up as a New York problem, not get smoothed into 'EURUSD was a bit heavier this week.' I don't recast the week in dollars-only either, because a gold $36 winner and a 0.9R forex winner are not the same story if I start comparing cash without R. Session first, R second, dollars third. Change the unit and I cannot compare weeks.

Re: I review the week in R by session, not by pair, because my London book and my New York book are not the same story

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 5:09 pm
by Fairman
A flat week is allowed to have a harsh conclusion. +3.0R and -3.0R is not 'nothing happened.' It is one book I should keep and one book I should shrink. The change can be as simple as New York going to 0.13 lot and $20.80 on a 16-pip EURUSD stop, while London stays at 0.25 lot and $40. I don't need a new strategy for EURUSD. I need a smaller New York, or a later start, or a hard pass after 14:30 until the session total stops leaking. The pair was never the diagnosis.

Re: I review the week in R by session, not by pair, because my London book and my New York book are not the same story

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2026 8:04 pm
by Fairman
I also don't rescue the New York column by hunting a Friday overlap winner at full size. That is how a -3.0R session becomes a -4.0R session with one extra ticket. If I take a Friday New York trade at all, it is at the already-cut size, and it is a setup I would have taken on a fresh week, not a repair job. The journal review is for Monday's rules, not for Friday afternoon pride. The $120 London made is already in the account. I don't have to give New York a chance to earn it back before the close.