M1 wick rejections: real signal or just the spread breathing?
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:26 pm
Long wicks on the one-minute chart get a lot of attention. A candle that spikes below a level and closes back above it looks like a clear rejection, and plenty of scalping setups are built on that idea. But on M1 it's worth being careful about what a wick actually represents.
Most retail charts show bid prices only. When the spread widens briefly, the bid can dip sharply even if no real selling happened, simply because the market maker widened their quote. That produces a wick on the chart that looks like a rejection but is really a spread event. It's most common around rollover, at the open, and in the seconds around data releases.
Another source is thin liquidity. In quiet periods, a single moderately sized order can push price a few pips before the book refills. The resulting wick shows that liquidity was thin at that moment, not that buyers stepped in at a meaningful level.
Real rejections tend to have some supporting features. They form at a level that matters on a higher timeframe, they happen during active hours, and the following candles confirm the move rather than drifting back into the wick. A wick in the middle of nowhere at 11 PM London time is much less informative than one at yesterday's low during the London morning.
One way to check how reliable wicks are on your own feed is to compare charts from two different brokers. If a wick only appears on one of them, it's probably a feed or spread artefact rather than something the market actually did.
Does anyone filter wick setups by time of day or by session? It would be interesting to hear whether that improves how often they follow through.
Most retail charts show bid prices only. When the spread widens briefly, the bid can dip sharply even if no real selling happened, simply because the market maker widened their quote. That produces a wick on the chart that looks like a rejection but is really a spread event. It's most common around rollover, at the open, and in the seconds around data releases.
Another source is thin liquidity. In quiet periods, a single moderately sized order can push price a few pips before the book refills. The resulting wick shows that liquidity was thin at that moment, not that buyers stepped in at a meaningful level.
Real rejections tend to have some supporting features. They form at a level that matters on a higher timeframe, they happen during active hours, and the following candles confirm the move rather than drifting back into the wick. A wick in the middle of nowhere at 11 PM London time is much less informative than one at yesterday's low during the London morning.
One way to check how reliable wicks are on your own feed is to compare charts from two different brokers. If a wick only appears on one of them, it's probably a feed or spread artefact rather than something the market actually did.
Does anyone filter wick setups by time of day or by session? It would be interesting to hear whether that improves how often they follow through.