How to review a losing week without rewriting your rules
Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:41 pm
A losing week is the most tempting time to change a strategy, and often the worst time to do it. The losses are fresh, every rule that was followed feels like it caused the damage, and the ideas for "improvements" come very easily. The trouble is that a week is usually far too small a sample to tell whether anything is actually broken.
A review that stays useful without turning into a rewrite might go something like this:
First, separate execution from the strategy. Were the trades taken the way the plan said? Entries, stops, size, timing. If not, the problem is discipline, and changing the rules won't fix it.
Second, check whether the week fits the strategy's known range. If historical results show losing weeks of this size happen every so often, this one may just be one of those. If it's far outside anything seen before, that's a stronger signal.
Third, look for a change in conditions. Was volatility unusually low or high, was there a major event, did spreads behave differently? A strategy struggling in an unusual week is different from one failing in ordinary conditions.
Fourth, write down any rule change ideas but don't apply them yet. Test them on past data first, and if they still look good, introduce them on purpose, not in reaction to a few bad days.
Keeping that separation between "what happened this week" and "what should change" protects a strategy from being tweaked into something that only fits the last five sessions.
How do others structure a review after a bad week?
A review that stays useful without turning into a rewrite might go something like this:
First, separate execution from the strategy. Were the trades taken the way the plan said? Entries, stops, size, timing. If not, the problem is discipline, and changing the rules won't fix it.
Second, check whether the week fits the strategy's known range. If historical results show losing weeks of this size happen every so often, this one may just be one of those. If it's far outside anything seen before, that's a stronger signal.
Third, look for a change in conditions. Was volatility unusually low or high, was there a major event, did spreads behave differently? A strategy struggling in an unusual week is different from one failing in ordinary conditions.
Fourth, write down any rule change ideas but don't apply them yet. Test them on past data first, and if they still look good, introduce them on purpose, not in reaction to a few bad days.
Keeping that separation between "what happened this week" and "what should change" protects a strategy from being tweaked into something that only fits the last five sessions.
How do others structure a review after a bad week?