Is the first pullback after a news spike tradeable, or just noise?
Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:11 pm
After a big release like NFP or CPI, the first move is mostly machines and stops. Then price usually snaps back part of the way within a minute or two, and a lot of short-term traders treat that first pullback as the "real" entry. The question is whether that pullback has any structure to it, or whether it's just the order book refilling after being emptied.
A few things are worth separating:
The size of the surprise. When the number is far from consensus, the first spike often holds and the pullback is shallow. When the number is close to expectations, the spike is mostly positioning being flushed out, and the pullback can retrace the whole move.
The spread during the pullback. In the first one or two minutes spreads are often still wide, so a pullback entry can cost several times the normal spread before the trade has even started.
Whether the move continues in other markets. If bond yields or the index futures keep going in the spike's direction while the currency pulls back, the pullback has a better reason to be bought. If everything else has already reversed, the currency is probably next.
One way to test this without much effort is to take the last 30 or 40 high-impact releases on one pair, mark the high or low of the first two minutes, and record how often price revisits that extreme within the next 15 minutes versus breaking back through the pre-release level. It won't give a strategy on its own, but it tells you whether the pullback idea even has a base rate worth trading.
For those who trade news, do you wait for the first pullback, wait longer for the dust to settle, or avoid the first 15 minutes altogether?
A few things are worth separating:
The size of the surprise. When the number is far from consensus, the first spike often holds and the pullback is shallow. When the number is close to expectations, the spike is mostly positioning being flushed out, and the pullback can retrace the whole move.
The spread during the pullback. In the first one or two minutes spreads are often still wide, so a pullback entry can cost several times the normal spread before the trade has even started.
Whether the move continues in other markets. If bond yields or the index futures keep going in the spike's direction while the currency pulls back, the pullback has a better reason to be bought. If everything else has already reversed, the currency is probably next.
One way to test this without much effort is to take the last 30 or 40 high-impact releases on one pair, mark the high or low of the first two minutes, and record how often price revisits that extreme within the next 15 minutes versus breaking back through the pre-release level. It won't give a strategy on its own, but it tells you whether the pullback idea even has a base rate worth trading.
For those who trade news, do you wait for the first pullback, wait longer for the dust to settle, or avoid the first 15 minutes altogether?