Page 1 of 1

Cutting winners short and sitting on losers: how to check

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:32 am
by Shadow Trader
Everyone knows the old line about cutting losers and letting winners run. Plenty of traders would tell you they do exactly that. Writing a short note on every trade about how it was managed, even for a month, often paints a less flattering picture.

It's worth checking whether the average winner is being held for a much shorter time than the average loser. In other words, the losing trades are being left on longer than the winning ones, which is the opposite of what most people would say if you asked them.

Two patterns tend to explain it. On winners, it's easy to close as soon as price stalls near a round number or a recent high, even when the target is further away. On losers, stops usually aren't being moved further away, which is good, but early-exit signals get ignored while the trader waits to see if price will come back. Sometimes it does, which makes it worse, because those occasional rescues teach people to hope.

One thing that helps is a timer. If a trade hasn't hit the target or the stop after a set number of minutes, close it at market regardless. That cuts the hoping on the losers. For the winners, it can also help to stop watching the P&L number and keep only the chart and the levels on screen.

It won't fix everything overnight, but the gap between the holding times often narrows. Worth writing down for a month if you've never checked.