Stops fill at the next price, and gaps make that painful
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:21 pm
A stop-loss isn't a guarantee of the exit price. It becomes a market order when triggered, and fills at the best available price after that. In an orderly market, the difference is a fraction of a pip. In a gap, it can be large.
Take a long position with a stop at 1.0950. The market jumps from 1.0960 to 1.0930 on a headline, with no trades in between. The stop triggers, and the fill comes at around 1.0930, twenty pips worse than planned.
Brokers describe this honestly in their terms, but few traders think about it until it happens. Some offer guaranteed stops, which fill at the specified price regardless, for a premium or a wider spread.
Slippage on stops is also asymmetric in most cases. Because stops trigger during adverse, fast moves, the slippage they suffer is larger than that on limit orders, which fill at passive levels.
For scalpers, the average cost of stop slippage can be measured. Take all stop-loss exits in a log, calculate the difference between the stop level and the fill, and compare it to the same difference on take-profits.
The result often shows the real cost of risk control.
Guaranteed stops exist at some brokers, and the cost is often built into the spread or charged as a premium when triggered. They tend to be available only on certain pairs and with minimum distances. For a scalper whose stop is very close to the entry, the minimum distance often makes them unusable.
Another approach is to avoid holding positions through known gap risks: weekends, major events, and illiquid hours. Where that isn't possible, reducing size so that a gap through the stop costs an acceptable amount is the practical defense.
Examining historical slippage on stops is informative. Sorting stop-outs by time of day and event shows when the worst slippage occurred. In most logs, the bulk of the cost comes from a handful of events, not from routine trades.
Knowing that distribution allows a more accurate estimate of risk than assuming the stop distance is the maximum loss.
Do stop-outs slip more than take-profits in the trading log, and by how much?
Take a long position with a stop at 1.0950. The market jumps from 1.0960 to 1.0930 on a headline, with no trades in between. The stop triggers, and the fill comes at around 1.0930, twenty pips worse than planned.
Brokers describe this honestly in their terms, but few traders think about it until it happens. Some offer guaranteed stops, which fill at the specified price regardless, for a premium or a wider spread.
Slippage on stops is also asymmetric in most cases. Because stops trigger during adverse, fast moves, the slippage they suffer is larger than that on limit orders, which fill at passive levels.
For scalpers, the average cost of stop slippage can be measured. Take all stop-loss exits in a log, calculate the difference between the stop level and the fill, and compare it to the same difference on take-profits.
The result often shows the real cost of risk control.
Guaranteed stops exist at some brokers, and the cost is often built into the spread or charged as a premium when triggered. They tend to be available only on certain pairs and with minimum distances. For a scalper whose stop is very close to the entry, the minimum distance often makes them unusable.
Another approach is to avoid holding positions through known gap risks: weekends, major events, and illiquid hours. Where that isn't possible, reducing size so that a gap through the stop costs an acceptable amount is the practical defense.
Examining historical slippage on stops is informative. Sorting stop-outs by time of day and event shows when the worst slippage occurred. In most logs, the bulk of the cost comes from a handful of events, not from routine trades.
Knowing that distribution allows a more accurate estimate of risk than assuming the stop distance is the maximum loss.
Do stop-outs slip more than take-profits in the trading log, and by how much?