forex-scalping.com

Moving average ribbons: useful or just colourful

A moving average ribbon is a set of several moving averages of different lengths plotted together, say eight of them from 10 to 80. When they're spread out and stacked in order, the trend is strong. When they twist together, the market is ranging or turning.

It looks impressive, and it does show something real. The spacing between the averages reflects how far price has moved from its recent averages over different periods. Wide spacing means momentum. Tight spacing means indecision.

The catch is that it's all from the same data. Eight averages of closing prices don't give you eight pieces of information. They give you one, shown eight ways. Two averages, a fast and a slow, tell you most of what the ribbon tells you.

Where I think a ribbon helps is visually. It's easier to see the trend state at a glance than reading two lines. If that helps you stay out of choppy conditions, fine.

Where it hurts is signals. People try to trade the ribbon crossing over, and that comes late, after the trend has already moved a lot. The full ribbon flipping order is a lagging confirmation, not an entry.

I'd use it as background, if at all, and keep entries based on something closer to price.

The settings make a big difference. A ribbon of short averages, like 5 to 30, reacts quickly and twists often. A ribbon of long ones, like 20 to 200, stays ordered for long stretches and hardly twists at all. Neither is right in general. It depends on the timeframe and how long you hold trades. If you hold for an hour on M5, a ribbon spanning roughly the last few hours makes more sense than one covering several days of bars. Matching the span of the ribbon to your usual holding time is a reasonable rule of thumb if you do use one.

Exponential averages make the ribbon react faster than simple ones, which changes how it looks around turns. With simple averages, the ribbon stays twisted longer after a reversal. With exponential, it reorders more quickly. If you compare ribbons on different platforms or screenshots, check which type is used. A lot of the arguments about ribbons on forums come down to people using different settings and seeing different pictures from the same price data. Writing down your exact settings when you share a ribbon screenshot saves a lot of back and forth in the replies.

Ribbons are useful mostly for one thing: showing at a glance whether price is trending cleanly or chopping. As entry signals, they tend to be late, because the twist happens after the turn.

For scalpers, a practical way to use a ribbon is as a filter. Trade only in the direction of the ribbon when it is fully stacked, and stay out completely when it is twisted. That removes many trades in choppy conditions, which is where most M1 strategies lose money. The exact lengths matter less than consistency.

Spacing between the averages can be measured rather than just looked at. The distance between the fastest and slowest average in the ribbon, divided by ATR, gives a number for how stretched the trend is. A very wide ribbon, much wider than normal, often comes before a pullback, since price has moved far from its averages. A tight ribbon, on the other hand, often comes before a breakout. Turning the visual into a number makes it easier to use consistently and to test, instead of relying on how the colours look on the day.

Do people use the ribbon for exits rather than entries? It might be a better fit. In a trend trade, price staying above the whole ribbon suggests the trend is strong. When price closes inside the ribbon, the trend might be weakening, and that could be a cue to tighten the stop or take partial profit. When price closes below the slowest average, the trend is probably over. Using the ribbon in stages like this gives a gradual exit rather than waiting for a single crossover signal that tends to come late.

FXS Prop Desk my experience was a bit different mate, i tried the stay out completely when twisted rule on M5 for a few months and it kept me out of the first half of every decent move, as the ribbon was still tangled when it started. What worked better for me was just halving my size while its twisted instead of sitting on my hands... bit less tidy but i recieved fewer of those "should have been in that" moments. Mostly gave me something to moan about other than Leeds, cheers.