Page 1 of 1

Head-to-head: which raw account wins London EURUSD this quarter?

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2026 3:50 pm
by LondonScalper
Head-to-head raw accounts on London EURUSD is a quarterly cost race, not a brand loyalty test.

I run the same hours, similar size, and I compare all-in cost plus reject behaviour. One account can win January and lose March if the open behaviour drifts. The winner is whichever clears my filter more often with less drama — not whichever logo I prefer.

Race rules
1. Identical session windows.
2. Enough fills to talk about medians.
3. News minutes parked separately.

If the race is close, I keep both with clear roles. If one is consistently worse, capital moves without a farewell essay.

What metrics decide your London EURUSD raw-account winner each quarter — spread only, or rejects and reliability too?

I keep the quarterly winner note only in the scorecard. Public crowing about brokers helps no one and ages badly when next quarter flips. Quiet capital moves are enough.

Rejects and weekend maintenance notes can break a tie when spreads look similar. Reliability is part of cost.

I revisit this on the Sunday review with costs in the same pass as entries. Process without cost is half a conversation, and cost without process is just a spreadsheet hobby.

Re: Head-to-head: which raw account wins London EURUSD this quarter?

Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 3:25 am
by Shadow Trader
I run the same race and the metric that decides it for me is all-in cost per London EURUSD fill, with rejects counted as a hard fail rather than a soft note. Spread alone crowned the wrong account two quarters in a row before I added the reject column.

Chart below is a synthetic EURUSD M1 view of the first half hour after 08:00 London on a quiet Tuesday. One account sits near 0.2 pips, the other spikes to about 1.1 around 08:04 while my usual entry window is open.
img_12633_r1.png
img_12633_r1.png (64.76 KiB) Viewed 373 times
I park news minutes in a separate sheet so a single CPI morning cannot flip the quarter. With roughly eighty fills per account the median settles; under forty I treat the ranking as provisional.

When the race is close I keep both with roles. One handles the open, the other the mid-morning grind, and capital only moves after two consecutive quarters of clear gap.

Reliability notes from weekend maintenance also break ties for me. An account that looks cheap on Tuesday and rejects stops on a Friday open is not the winner on my sheet.

Reject rate sits equal to cost on my scorecard, not as a soft note. Do you weight it the same, or only as a tie breaker?

Re: Head-to-head: which raw account wins London EURUSD this quarter?

Posted: Fri Oct 16, 2026 12:38 am
by Shadow Trader
LondonScalper, commission and swap belong in the all-in cost per fill or the race crowns the wrong raw account again. One book looked 0.05 pips tighter on spread and lost by 0.2 once round turn commission sat in the same unit.

Holiday weeks contaminate the quarterly sample for me. A thin Christmas open with three rejects can flip a median built on eighty quiet fills, so I tag those sessions and exclude them from the race unless both accounts traded the same week.

When capital moves it is a ratio, not a farewell. The loser keeps a third of the London EURUSD size for a quarter as a live control, and only goes to zero after another clear gap.

That stops me from romanticising the winner when its open behaviour drifts in March. The control book either confirms the gap or earns size back.

Reliability notes from weekend maintenance still break ties, and I weight a Friday open reject equal to about 0.15 pips of extra median cost over the quarter.

Do you exclude holiday weeks from the eighty fill count, or leave them in and accept the noise?

Re: Head-to-head: which raw account wins London EURUSD this quarter?

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:01 pm
by Shadow Trader
Quarter-end brings flows that have nothing to do with charts. Fund managers rebalance portfolios, corporates settle hedges and banks adjust balance sheets.

In forex, the effect appears as sudden movements into the London fix on the last trading day of the quarter, unusual spreads on short-dated swaps and occasional spikes in funding costs. Rates in cross-currency basis markets can move noticeably.

For spot traders, the practical consequence is erratic price behaviour in the final days. Reversals appear at odd times. Breakouts lack follow-through. Month-end already has this character, and quarter-end amplifies it.

Another oddity arrives right after: the first days of a new quarter often bring fresh flows and changes in trend, since mandates reset.

A calendar with the last three trading days of each quarter highlighted gives early warning, and many scalpers reduce size for that window.

Has quarter-end ever damaged a trading week here, and did it fit the pattern?

Re: Head-to-head: which raw account wins London EURUSD this quarter?

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:16 pm
by Amanhasnoname
I run something similar with two raw accounts, though on a smaller sample, and rejects decide it for me more often than spread. One of my brokers was cheaper on paper every month, but in the first few minutes after London opened it would requote or reject a noticeable share of orders. Each of those cost me a worse re-entry, and once I counted that in, the cheaper account lost.

I weight rejects as a cost rather than a tie-breaker. I give every reject a rough price, based on how far price moved before I got filled on the retry, and add it into the all-in figure. It's not precise, but it stops a tight spread from hiding a bad execution habit. Commission goes in too, otherwise the comparison means nothing.

On the quarter-end point raised above, I'd keep those last few days out of the race entirely. Spreads and fills get odd on both accounts, and one bad day can swing a quarter's median when the sample is small.