Page 1 of 1
FundedNext: comparing firm spreads to IC Markets raw
Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2026 2:55 pm
by LondonScalper
FundedNext versus IC Markets raw is another venue comparison that only matters with a boring sample.
I care about the pairs and hours I trade, not a global average from a marketing PDF. If the firm feed is acceptable on EURUSD London but poor on metals, that goes in the allowlist — not in a motivational speech about "prop is fine."
What I log
- Spread medians by session
- Reject behaviour on stop entries
- Whether firm rules force me flat when my personal playbook would still be active
Spread is one column. Rule friction is another. Both affect expectancy.
Anyone running FundedNext alongside a raw IC book — which pairs stayed on the firm, and which moved back to personal only?
Payout rules and news restrictions sit beside the spread columns. A firm can win on raw tightness and still lose for my desk if I cannot trade my real hours. Venue fit is multi-column, not a single medal.
I avoid declaring a forever winner. Firm conditions and my pair mix both move; the comparison is a living control, not a tattoo.
Re: FundedNext: comparing firm spreads to IC Markets raw
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 1:48 am
by Shadow Trader
One thing I'd add to the spread columns is commission, logged in the same unit. A firm quoting 0.6 pips with no commission and a raw account at 0.1 pips plus about 0.7 pips round turn in commission are much closer than the headline spreads suggest.
So my sheet converts everything to all in pips per round turn, per pair, per session. It's a boring column, but it decided which pairs stayed on the firm in my own comparison with a different firm.
I'd also log spread at the moments I actually trade, not just session medians. A London median can look fine while the first five minutes after 08:00, where most of my entries sit, are twice as wide on one feed.
I did it with a small script on both terminals writing bid and ask every second from 07:55 to 08:20. The two servers used different time zones, so I converted both to UTC first, otherwise the rows were an hour apart.
Your rule friction column is the one I'd weight most. A feed that's 0.1 pips tighter is worth little if a news restriction forces me flat through the hour I trade best.
How many London sessions is enough before trusting the medians? I stopped at twenty and it still felt thin.
Re: FundedNext: comparing firm spreads to IC Markets raw
Posted: Thu Oct 15, 2026 11:25 pm
by Shadow Trader
LondonScalper, I went back to my own question about sample size and checked how the gap between the two feeds moved as sessions were added. After ten London sessions the firm feed looked 0.15 pips wider at 08:00, after twenty it was 0.05, and it settled around 0.08 from thirty onwards.
So twenty was not enough for me, mainly because two or three wide data mornings could swing the median. I now want thirty sessions with at least three data mornings among them before I trust a column.
Your reject behaviour column turned out to matter more than the spread. Stop entries filled within 0.1 pips on one feed most mornings, while the other averaged about 0.3 of slip on the same entries in the first five minutes. That slip never shows up in a spread median, so it sits in its own column.
Rollover is one more hour to check if you ever hold past it. One feed widened to around 2 pips at the daily rollover and the other to 5, which only matters when a stop or target sits close.
Did FundedNext show a wider rollover than the raw account in your logs? I have not compared those two directly.
Re: FundedNext: comparing firm spreads to IC Markets raw
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 2:38 pm
by Shadow Trader
Raw spread accounts advertise spreads from 0.0 pips and add a commission. The structure looks transparent. Yet the underlying feed may still include a small markup.
Some brokers add a fraction of a pip to the raw price, then charge commission on top. The effect is a total cost higher than the headline suggests.
Comparing two brokers requires adding commission to spread, expressed in the same unit, and measuring both over identical conditions. A broker advertising 0.0 spread plus 7 dollars commission per lot round trip charges 0.7 pips. A competitor showing 0.3 spread with 3.5 dollars commission charges 0.65.
The difference is trivial per trade, though across thousands of trades it counts.
Spread behaviour in active sessions matters more than quoted averages. A broker whose raw spread rarely drops below 0.4 on EURUSD in live conditions has a markup, whatever the label.
How were the all-in costs of the current broker verified?