Page 1 of 1

September scalp review: what I change for next month

Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2026 6:32 pm
by LondonScalper
September scalp review: what I change for next month

Monthly reviews are where I stop lying to myself about “a few bad days.” September’s book usually shows the same sins in new clothes: late-NY overtime, gold size drift, and news curiosity dressed up as a plan. Without a fixed template I drift into storytelling.

My September template stays fixed year to year:
  • Cost per R by pair — not just win rate.
  • Which session produced expectancy after costs.
  • Which rule I broke most often (process score, not P&L).
  • One change only for next month. Not five “improvements.”
Last useful change from a September pass: earlier hard shut-off on Fridays. Give-back trades vanished from the log within two weeks. The discipline is choosing a single lever and measuring it, not redesigning the whole playbook because the month felt annoying.

If you do a monthly scalp review, what is the one change you are carrying into next month?

I keep the September file next to the prior two months so I can see whether the same rule-break keeps mutating. If the same sin appears three months running, the next change is environmental — earlier shut-off, smaller gold envelope — not another entry tweak.

Re: September scalp review: what I change for next month

Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2026 1:04 pm
by PropScalpDesk
One change for October from me, and it's a calendar one. Europe leaves summer time on 25 October, the US only on 1 November. For that week, US releases arrive an hour earlier on European clocks, so the 13:30 London prints move to 12:30. Every year somebody gets caught by a big US release during what they thought was lunch.

So my October change is just re-checking every blackout time for that week by hand instead of trusting last month's sheet.

On the method, one change per month is right, but it only works if you judge it on the same metric you picked it for. Your Friday shut-off is a good example: count of give-back trades before and after, not the monthly P&L, which has a dozen other things in it.

Re: September scalp review: what I change for next month

Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 12:13 am
by Shadow Trader
PropScalpDesk's clock point catches more than news times. Many platforms run server time tied to the New York close, so in the week between 25 October and 1 November the server clock sits an hour away from its usual gap to London.

Any EA or indicator with a session filter in server time drifts by an hour without warning. One year my Asian range box was drawn from the wrong hour, and I only noticed because the range looked oddly narrow on two mornings.

My September file had one ugly line. Of 19 rule breaks in the month, 13 came after 11:00 London, mostly small extra scalps on EURUSD once the morning plan was done. None of them were large, which is why the P&L never flagged the pattern.

So my October change is environmental, the way LondonScalper suggests: the platform closes at 11:00 and the morning plan simply has no afternoon section. I will judge it on rule breaks per week, not on the P&L.

The question I still struggle with is how long to give one change before calling it. Is a month enough when only about twenty sessions go into it?

Re: September scalp review: what I change for next month

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 1:35 am
by Shadow Trader
To answer my own question about how long, I wrote the pass mark down before the month started. September had 19 rule breaks, roughly five a week, so the 11:00 close passes if three of October's four weeks come in at two or fewer.

Fixing the mark in advance matters because twenty sessions can be read either way afterwards. A bad week can always be called unusual, and a good one can always be credited to the change.

So far this month the data shows something I had not planned for. The urge did not disappear, it moved, and three of my rule breaks landed between 10:30 and 11:00, the window just before the platform shuts.

So a time based fix seems to push the same habit up against the deadline. I have added a second line to the review, rule breaks in the last half hour before the close, so I can see whether the change is cutting the problem or just moving it.

PropScalpDesk's point about judging on the metric you picked applies here too. If the total falls but the last half hour fills up, I would count that as half a result and keep the change for another month.