Page 1 of 1
Naming the emotion before any size change
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2026 6:01 pm
by LondonScalper
Name the emotion before any size change
Size creep rarely announces itself as greed. It arrives as “confidence,” “I see it clearly,” or “this one needs room.” My fix is verbal and slightly embarrassing: I name the emotion out loud before I touch the lot field, even if I am alone in the room.
The rule is strict:
- If I want to increase size mid-session, I must say the word — boredom, euphoria, fear, FOMO, impatience — before the click.
- If I cannot name it cleanly in one word, size stays put.
- If the word is euphoria or revenge, size can only go down, never up, for the rest of that session.
It sounds theatrical. It is cheaper than a slipped stop on gold after a winner. Naming breaks the automatic hand that ups size because the last trade worked. On prop this matters twice: consistency rules notice clusters of oversized tickets dressed as “confidence.”
Do you require any explicit gate before resizing, or is lot size still a gut feel mid-flow?
Re: Naming the emotion before any size change
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2026 2:27 pm
by PropScalpDesk
I do a written version of this. The emotion word goes into the order comment field in MT5 before any size change. It's slower than saying it out loud, which is the point, and it's searchable. At the end of the month I can filter every ticket where the comment says "sure" or "obvious" and see how those did. Mine weren't pretty.
Re: Naming the emotion before any size change
Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 3:00 am
by Shadow Trader
I like that the rule only lets euphoria and revenge push size down. The gap I found when I tried something similar was the size change made before the session, which no mid-session gate catches.
After a good week I would open Monday at a bigger lot and call it planning. It was the same feeling as mid-session euphoria, just with a weekend in between, so the rule now covers the first ticket of the day too.
I also added a timer. Once the word is said, I wait two minutes before changing the lot, and roughly half the time the trade I wanted to size up is gone by then, which tells me something about it.
The comment field idea is good for the review side. My one tweak would be a fixed list of eight or so words, because free text drifts and after a month you have sure, certain, obvious and clear all meaning the same thing.
Does anyone apply the gate when cutting size after a loss? Fear shrinking a position seems harmless, but it can leave the next valid setup at a size that makes it pointless.
Re: Naming the emotion before any size change
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 4:27 am
by Shadow Trader
The loophole I ran into after a month of this was that I learned which words were safe. Calm and focused never triggered anything, so those became the words I reached for whenever I wanted to size up.
What fixed it was checking the words against the outcome rather than trusting them. Over about 120 tagged size changes, the ones I labelled calm did no better than the euphoria ones, which told me the label had turned into a password.
So the gate is now mechanical as well as verbal. Size can only move between three fixed steps, half, normal and one and a quarter, and only one step per session in either direction.
PropScalpDesk's comment field makes that audit easy, since MT5 exports the comment with every ticket. A monthly sort by word and by step size shows quickly whether a particular feeling keeps buying the bigger lot.
LondonScalper, does saying the word out loud still work for you after months of doing it? For me the spoken version faded first, and the written one lasted longer because I could read it back during the weekly review.
Re: Naming the emotion before any size change
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 2:20 pm
by Shadow Trader
An account grows from 2,000 to 10,000 dollars. Position size naturally rises with risk percentage fixed. The dollar amounts at stake are suddenly five times bigger.
The emotional reaction is different. A 1 percent loss that used to be 20 dollars is now 100. Many traders who handled small losses calmly find themselves hesitating, moving stops and exiting early.
The strategy has not changed. The psychology has.
A gradual approach helps. Increasing size in steps, such as 25 percent at a time after a set number of trades at the current size, lets emotions adapt.
Another practice is to think in percentages and R-multiples instead of dollars, keeping attention on the process.
Some traders reduce the account displayed on screen, hiding the balance and tracking only R.
A review after each size increase, checking for changes in execution quality and rule adherence, catches problems early.
Did increasing account size ever change behaviour here, and what helped?