Page 1 of 1

Passing FundedNext with M5 instead of M1: trade-offs

Posted: Fri Sep 18, 2026 6:00 pm
by LondonScalper
FundedNext on M5 instead of M1 — trade-offs

I scalp mostly on M1/M5 hybrid personally, but for a prop pass I experimented with M5-primary to cut noise, reduce trade count, and look more “consistent” under review. Results were mixed — worth discussing openly rather than pretending one timeframe is virtuous.

Trade-offs I saw:
  • + Fewer click-chain opportunities; easier to respect daily loss
  • + Stops based on clearer structure; less death-by-spread on tiny targets
  • − Slower feedback; easier to overstay a thesis
  • − Some London open edges I like simply do not wait for M5 closes
I am not saying M5 is safer — just that timeframe choice is part of prop risk design, not only “strategy.” Position size had to change too; the same R on a wider M5 stop means fewer concurrent ideas.

Anyone passed (or failed) by deliberately stepping up a timeframe? What did you change in R size when the chart slowed down?

Re: Passing FundedNext with M5 instead of M1: trade-offs

Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2026 11:08 am
by PropScalpDesk
When I moved up to M5, the stop roughly doubled, from about 6 pips to 11 or 12 on EURUSD, so the lot size halved and R stayed the same. What I hadn't expected was the effect on the day-to-day shape of the results. With about half as many trades, individual days got lumpier. One good M5 trade could be most of a week's profit.

That matters if the account has a consistency rule that caps how much of the total can come from one day. On M1 my best day was rarely a big share of the total; on M5 I came close to the cap twice in a month without doing anything differently. So if you step up a timeframe on a prop account, check the consistency maths as well as the drawdown maths.

Re: Passing FundedNext with M5 instead of M1: trade-offs

Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 2:16 am
by Shadow Trader
Before the first M5 trade I'd run the consistency rule numbers on paper. Say the challenge target is 8 percent and you risk 0.5 percent a trade, which makes the target 16R.

On M5 with a 1 to 2.5 reward, two clean winners on a Tuesday give 5R in a day. If the rule caps any single day at 40 percent of total profit, you then need at least 12.5R overall before that Tuesday stops being a problem, so you can end up trading past the target just to dilute one good day.

A simple fix I've used is a daily profit stop at about a third of the target. Once the day is up 5R I close the platform, which feels wrong on a strong trend but keeps the distribution flat.

The slower feedback also shows up in hold time. An M5 trade often lasts 40 minutes or more, so the odds of being in a position when a red folder release arrives go up, and on accounts with news rules that matters more than the spread saving.

Did you adjust the session window when you stepped up, or keep trading the same London hours? I found M5 needed a slightly earlier start to catch the first structure.

Re: Passing FundedNext with M5 instead of M1: trade-offs

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 3:46 am
by Shadow Trader
A rarely counted upside of the wider M5 stop is what it does to costs in R. With about 1.2 pips all in per round trip on EURUSD, a 6 pip M1 stop pays 0.2R per trade before anything happens, while a 12 pip M5 stop pays 0.1R.

Halve the trade count as well and the monthly bill falls to a quarter. Sixty M1 trades cost about 12R over a challenge month against about 3R for thirty M5 trades, and on a 16R target that difference is most of a good week.

The London open problem LondonScalper raised is real, though. Waiting for the 07:05 close on a fast open often means getting in 8 or 9 pips late, which eats most of the advantage on that one trade.

What I tried was letting M1 trigger only during the first fifteen minutes, with the M5 stop size kept. It worked on paper, but in practice I took more of those early trades than planned, so I dropped it and accepted missing some opens.

PropScalpDesk, when one good M5 trade made up most of a week, did you notice it changing how you traded the next few days? For me a big day was usually followed by a couple of careless ones.