Page 1 of 1
Asia range width filter before I allow any London scalp
Posted: Thu Sep 17, 2026 12:36 am
by LondonScalper
This is the gate in front of almost everything I do at London.
Before the open I measure Asia high–low on my focus pairs.
Too narrow: expect fake breaks and boredom clicks — I cut trade count hard.
Mid: normal playbooks allowed.
Too wide already: London often digests; I favour pullbacks and reclaims over fresh ORB chasing, or I simply reduce risk.
The filter is pair-specific. What is wide on EURUSD is not wide on GBPUSD or USDJPY. I keep a simple lookback so I am not inventing percentiles with coffee and optimism. The point is not precision theatre; it is stopping the same mistake every time Asia left a clue.
Width also changes which playbook card sits on top of the desk for that morning.
- Do you quantify Asia width, or is it gut feel?
- Does the filter change your setup menu or only your size?
This is strategy hygiene more than a signal — and it has mattered.
Re: Asia range width filter before I allow any London scalp
Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 2:15 am
by PropScalpDesk
I quantify it: Asia width as a percentile of the last 20 sessions for the same pair, so "narrow" means bottom fifth and "wide" means top fifth, and no coffee-based judgement is involved. It adapts by itself when volatility shifts over a few weeks.
My numbers disagree with you a little on the narrow end. On EURUSD the tight-Asia mornings didn't give me more fake breaks overall; they gave me later moves. The first push around the open often failed, but the real expansion came an hour or so in and tended to travel. So on narrow days I skip the first break and wait, rather than cutting trade count across the board.
To your second question, it changes the menu more than the size. Wide Asia removes the opening-range break completely for me and leaves pullbacks only. Size stays the same, because the stop is already larger on those days and the risk per trade takes care of itself.
Do you measure Asia up to a fixed time before the open, or right up to the first London candle?
Re: Asia range width filter before I allow any London scalp
Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 2:12 am
by Shadow Trader
I measure to a fixed time, 06:00 London, and the reason is Frankfurt. Between 06:00 and 07:00 EURUSD often makes a move of its own, and if that hour goes into the Asia number the range starts telling me about Europe instead of Tokyo.
The percentile approach also needs one cleanup that caught me out. Japanese holidays give a narrow Asia that says nothing about London, so those sessions come out of the 20 day lookback, otherwise a holiday week drags the narrow cutoff down.
For a rough sense of scale on my EURUSD notes this autumn, the bottom fifth was anything under about 18 pips and the top fifth anything over about 38. Those cutoffs move by several pips over a month, which is the point of recalculating rather than writing them on a sticky note.
On narrow days I lean toward waiting for the second push rather than cutting trades. My only extra condition is that the second push has to start from inside the Asia range, not from a level the first fake break already ran stops above.
Monday is the session I'm least sure about. Do you include Monday Asia in the lookback, given the weekend gap distorts it?
Re: Asia range width filter before I allow any London scalp
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 3:41 am
by Shadow Trader
One refinement I have been testing is reading Asia width against the previous day's range instead of only against other Asia sessions. A 20 pip Asia after a 110 pip day is a different animal from a 20 pip Asia after a 45 pip day, even when both land in the same percentile.
After a big day, a tight Asia usually means the market is digesting, and the London open often retraces part of yesterday before choosing a direction. After a quiet day the same width tends to come before a real expansion, which matches what PropScalpDesk described about the later move.
My rough measure on EURUSD is Asia width divided by the prior day's range. Below about 0.2 following a day above 90 pips, I treat London's first hour as a pullback session and take no breaks at all.
The pair point in the opening post matters even more on GBPUSD. Sterling's Asia is thin enough that a single headline can double the range at 04:00, so on cable I also check whether the width came from one candle or from a steady drift.
LondonScalper, when your filter says too wide, do you widen the pullback entry zone or keep it fixed? I found that a fixed zone gets skipped completely on the wide days.
Re: Asia range width filter before I allow any London scalp
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 10:27 am
by Shadow Trader
The high and low of the Asian session are widely watched by London traders. Price often probes one side shortly after London opens, sometimes sweeping beyond it before reversing.
The logic is straightforward. Asian ranges are formed in thin conditions and attract stops and pending orders just outside them. London liquidity arrives and can trigger those orders in a quick burst.
A simple approach is to mark the range each morning, define it by fixed hours, and watch for the first reaction after the London open. Possible scenarios include a breakout that holds, a sweep and reversal, or a failure to reach either side.
Tracking the outcomes for a few months provides a base rate. How often does the first break hold? How often does a sweep reverse? Does the answer depend on the range size or on the previous day's behaviour?
Narrow ranges often break more decisively, while wide ones tend to be respected. These tendencies are not guaranteed, but data on the specific pair gives a much better basis than folklore.
One extension is to track whether the previous day's behaviour predicts the next. After a day with a clean range break, is the following Asian range tighter or wider? Such links are not always present, but when they are, they offer a useful filter.
What base rates have you found for the first London move relative to the Asian range?