Page 1 of 1

FVG created in the London first hour: trade it or leave it?

Posted: Thu Sep 17, 2026 12:05 am
by LondonScalper
London’s first hour manufactures imbalances constantly. Trading all of them is a quiet tax.

I leave most first-hour FVGs alone unless they align with a higher-timeframe level or a clear sweep story. Fresh M1 gaps in the middle of the open drive are often just impulse exhaust, not destinations worth fading or chasing. Marking them is fine; clicking them because they exist is not.

Rule: new FVG during the London first hour is a watchlist mark, not an automatic order. I prefer to trade reactions later in the morning or into the overlap if price returns with structure. If the imbalance is immediately filled and forgotten, that tells you something about how much "edge" was there.

Session timing filters have improved my FVG results more than finer gap geometry.
  • Do you trade first-hour FVGs or wait for price to come back later?
  • Any pair where first-hour FVG fills are consistently worth it?
Preference for process over folklore.

Re: FVG created in the London first hour: trade it or leave it?

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2026 1:56 pm
by PropScalpDesk
Most London first-hour FVGs are tax

London’s opening hour prints imbalances constantly. Treating each as a destination is how I used to donate commission. From Frankfurt I mark many first-hour FVGs and click almost none.

I engage only when the imbalance sits with a higher-timeframe level or a clear sweep story, and when the drive has shown some acceptance rather than pure exhaust. Fresh M1 gaps mid-impulse are often just speed, not a gift.

Concrete rule: first-hour FVG alone is observation. FVG plus HTF level plus a reclaim/rejection trigger can be a ticket. Time stop is short; if price leaves without me, I do not chase the midpoint later out of completionism.

Another filter I use: if the first-hour FVG sits against the higher-timeframe open drive rather than with it, I need even more confluence or I leave it. Fighting the open with a pretty gap is a recurring expensive hobby.

Do you grade first-hour FVGs by session phase, or do you still treat every gap as equal weight on the chart?

Re: FVG created in the London first hour: trade it or leave it?

Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 1:17 am
by Shadow Trader
I grade them by age rather than by phase. A first hour gap only earns a place on the order list if it is still untouched at 09:00 London, and anything filled before then gets deleted from my screen.

I logged every M1 and M5 gap on EURUSD and GBPUSD for about two months to see whether that filter was doing anything. Roughly two in three first hour gaps were filled inside the same hour, and those fills ran straight through the gap far more often than they reacted to it.

The ones that survived to 09:00 were fewer but behaved better on a later return, especially into the London lunch dip. Even then I only took them with the higher timeframe level PropScalpDesk mentions, so the gap was really the entry location rather than the reason.

On LondonScalper's pair question, GBPUSD gaps held a little better than EURUSD ones in my sample. Gold was the worst, with gaps so frequent in the first hour that marking them all was pointless.

How do you draw the gap itself, wick to wick or using the middle candle's body? My numbers changed noticeably depending on which one I used.

Re: FVG created in the London first hour: trade it or leave it?

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 2:36 am
by Shadow Trader
To answer my own drawing question, I settled on wick to wick, measured from the high of the first candle to the low of the third. The body version gave me far more gaps, and most of the extra ones were too thin to hold an order and a stop inside them.

Size became the second filter after age. On EURUSD I now ignore any first hour gap smaller than about 1.5 pips, since the spread at the open can eat a third of it before price even arrives.

On GBPUSD the floor is closer to 2 pips, which may be part of why its gaps looked better in my log. The ones I kept there were simply bigger and easier to trade cleanly.

PropScalpDesk's short time stop is the piece I copy directly. If price reaches the far edge of the gap and has not moved back toward my target within five M1 candles, I close it, because a gap that gets accepted inside tends to fill completely.

Do you use a size floor as well, or does the higher timeframe level do that job for you? I can see the argument that a big gap at a weak level is still worse than a small one at a strong level.

Re: FVG created in the London first hour: trade it or leave it?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 4:14 am
by Shadow Trader
Supply and demand zones are areas where price made a sharp departure, often drawn as boxes rather than lines. The idea is that unfilled orders remain there, and price will react on return.

The concept has some logic. If a large order was only partly filled before price left, the rest may still be waiting. But that logic applies to institutional-sized orders, and retail charts can't see them. Any box on a chart is an inference.

To test the idea, define zones mechanically: a base of two to five small candles followed by an impulse of at least a set multiple of ATR. Mark each zone automatically, then record what happens on the first return: bounce, break, or ambiguity. Compare outcomes across hundreds of zones, and separate fresh zones from tested ones, since the claim is that untouched zones work best.

Results often show something modest: a slight edge at first touch that decays rapidly with each retest. Whether it survives spread and slippage is another question.

A cleaner way to define the base: require at least three candles with bodies smaller than 30% of ATR, followed by a candle at least 1.5 times ATR in size. Mark the zone from the base's high to its low. Then watch the first return, and record how far price moves in the next 10 candles.

Interesting subtleties show up in the data. Zones created at the London open tend to behave differently from zones created in the Asian afternoon. Zones near round numbers get more reactions than zones in the middle of nowhere. And zones that were created by news-driven candles often fail, since the move wasn't about order imbalance at all.

Splitting results by these factors usually turns a vague method into a few concrete rules, or into a pile of discarded ideas.

Has an automated zone test been run, and what happened on first return versus second return?