Page 1 of 1
When impulse pullback fails on EURJPY: my abort criteria
Posted: Wed Sep 16, 2026 10:47 pm
by LondonScalper
Having an entry rule without an abort rule is how EURJPY turns a small idea into a session wound.
My impulse–pullback on EURJPY is aborted when any of these hit: (1) pullback extends beyond half of the impulse with acceptance, not just a wick; (2) a lower timeframe break of the pullback structure goes against me and holds; or (3) time expires with no continuation. Any one is enough. I do not wait for all three like a committee.
I do not add. I do not "wait for London lunch to calm". Flatten, tag the reason, move on. If yen headlines are dripping, abort sensitivity goes up — I would rather be flat than negotiate with a cross under policy noise.
Re-entry the same morning needs a fresh impulse, not a hope that the old one resurrects.
- What is your hard abort on failed pullbacks?
- Do you allow one re-entry after abort, or is that the day’s idea done?
Especially interested in EURJPY-specific quirks versus the majors.
Re: When impulse pullback fails on EURJPY: my abort criteria
Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 6:11 am
by PropScalpDesk
One re-entry, and only after price prints a new impulse extreme. Otherwise the idea is done for the morning, same as your fresh-impulse rule.
The EURJPY quirk that matters for criterion (1): the cross is two moves stacked. A pullback that's really USDJPY dropping on a yen headline while EURUSD sits still behaves differently from the euro itself being sold. The yen-driven ones are sharper and can keep going, because the headline hits every yen pair at once. I keep USDJPY in a small window beside the cross for that reason.
"Acceptance" for me is two consecutive M1 closes past the halfway point. Crude, but it ends the debate.
Re: When impulse pullback fails on EURJPY: my abort criteria
Posted: Fri Oct 16, 2026 9:03 pm
by Shadow Trader
Criterion 3 is the one I had to put a number on, because time expires can stretch to fit any mood. Mine is six M1 bars from the pullback low, and if price has not made a new high beyond the impulse by then, the trade is closed at whatever it shows.
On the two moves point PropScalpDesk makes, I check it with simple arithmetic rather than by eye. The percentage move in EURJPY is close to the EURUSD move plus the USDJPY move, so if a 0.15 percent pullback in the cross has 0.12 of it coming from USDJPY, it is a yen move.
Those yen driven pullbacks get a tighter abort from me. Acceptance is one M1 close past halfway rather than two, because the second close often arrives 10 pips later on a headline.
On re-entry I am stricter than one per morning. After an abort tagged as yen driven I leave EURJPY alone until the next session, since the same headline flow tends to hit again within the hour.
Do you keep the abort rules the same on the Tokyo side of the day? I only trade the cross in London, so I have no data for it.
Re: When impulse pullback fails on EURJPY: my abort criteria
Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 10:59 pm
by Shadow Trader
Since my last post I went back and checked what price did after each abort, which is the only way I know to see whether the rules cut good trades. Over two months I logged 34 aborts on EURJPY and followed each one for 30 minutes afterwards.
Nine of them would have reached the original target, and the other 25 hit the stop or went well past it. The aborted exits cost me about 0.45R on average, against a full 1R if I had let the stop do the work.
The interesting part was which rule fired. Six of those nine came from criterion 2, the lower timeframe break, which makes it the noisiest of the three on my log.
My guess is that an M1 structure break on the cross is often just one of the two legs wobbling. I now require that break to hold for two closes before it counts, the same test PropScalpDesk uses for acceptance.
The time stop was the cleanest. Only one of its aborts would have worked, so I left that rule exactly as it was.
Has anyone else run this kind of regret check on their abort rules? I suspect most of us only remember the aborts that would have paid.