Page 1 of 1
IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes
Posted: Mon Sep 14, 2026 11:31 pm
by LondonScalper
IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes.
Another pair-wise cost thread for people who actually log. I look at London open median spread, commission to points, slippage distribution (not averages only), and reject counts on market vs limit. EURUSD is liquid enough that differences can be small -- which means sample size matters and narrative does not.
I also note platform feel (MT5/cTrader) because a slower cancel costs money even if the spread looks fine.
Share numbers if you have them; skip slogans. What does your last month of EURUSD clicks say?
If differences are within noise, stay put -- switching tax is real. Obsessing over a tenth of a point while process leaks whole R is common. Use comparison to catch outliers and stress weeks, not to feed perpetual FOMO about venues.
I am interested in how others on this desk handle the same problem without turning it into folklore. Concrete rules and log fields beat slogans. If you have a version of "IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes" that survived contact with live sessions, what does the rule look like on a sticky note -- and what did you try that failed?
Re: IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2026 7:24 pm
by Shadow Trader
Agree that median spread at the open is the first field, but I'd add one you didn't list: the time between your order and the fill, logged per ticket. On EURUSD two venues can show nearly identical spreads and still differ by 40 or 50 ms on confirmation at 08:00, and that is where the slip distribution comes from.
On sample size, my rough rule is at least 200 tickets per venue in the same session window before I believe a difference under 0.1 pips. Below that, one news morning can swing the whole comparison.
I also split limit and market orders completely. A limit book that fills you only when price comes through your level looks fantastic on slippage and quietly costs you missed trades. I count missed limit fills as a cost, using the move I didn't get.
One edge case: commission charged per side versus round turn. When I convert both to points per lot, I always double check which one the statement shows, because I once compared one venue's per side figure to another's round turn and thought I'd found a bargain.
How are you measuring reject counts on market orders? Requotes, or anything the terminal flags as off quotes?
Re: IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 10:08 pm
by Shadow Trader
Another angle on this: the switching tax you mention is bigger than most people count. It isn't only the paperwork. Every venue has its own server time, symbol names, swap timing and stop level rules, and my first two weeks on a new account are always worse.
When I moved accounts in spring, I tracked it. My error count, wrong lot size or a template that loaded with the wrong levels, went from about one a month to five in the first fortnight. None were big, but they all cost something.
So now I only consider moving if the difference survives three separate months of logging, not one. A single good month for the new venue is usually a quiet month for the market.
I'd also run both side by side at small size for a few weeks before moving anything serious. Same setups, same times, 0.1 lots on each. It's the only fair comparison I've found, because otherwise you're comparing different market days.
Has anyone actually seen a difference that held up over a full quarter on EURUSD? I suspect most of them fade.
Re: IC Markets vs Eightcap on EURUSD: cost and fill notes
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:51 pm
by Shadow Trader
A market order for 5 lots on a thin pair doesn't always get filled in one piece. On true ECN or STP accounts, the order walks through the available depth. The first lot might fill at 1.08502, the second and third at 1.08503, the fourth at 1.08505, and the rest later or not at all.
On MT4 that often appears as several separate tickets, or one ticket with an average price. On MT5 the deal list shows each partial fill, along with the order type and the fill policy, such as fill or kill, immediate or cancel, or return.
The setting matters. Fill or kill rejects the entire order if it can't be filled completely. Immediate or cancel takes what's available and cancels the rest. Return lets the remainder sit as a pending order, which can leave a position half open when the price runs away.
Size is the usual cause. A few hundred dollars of risk on EURUSD rarely sees a partial fill. A bigger ticket on GBPNZD in Asia absolutely can.
The practical thing is to know which filling policy the broker uses by default and what the platform does when the book is thin. Few traders read this part of the order window.
Brokers also differ on whether they report the average fill price or each fill separately. A statement showing the average hides the depth walk, and only the detailed deal list reveals how much worse the later fills were than the first.
For anyone sizing up on thin pairs, comparing the average fill with the first quote, for a few orders at different sizes, shows how quickly the cost grows with size.
Has a partial fill ever left a position at a size that wasn't intended?