Page 1 of 1

Partial fills on XAUUSD: how I log them and when I cancel the rest

Posted: Sat Sep 12, 2026 8:36 pm
by LondonScalper
Gold execution note — partial fills, not a gold call.

On XAUUSD I still see tickets that fill in pieces, especially around the London–NY handoff or when the tape is thin. Treating a partial as “the full idea” has cost me more than the spread ever did.

My logging fields
• Intended size vs filled size
• Time gap between slices
• Mid at first fill vs mid at last fill
• Whether I cancelled the residual or let it work

Decision rule I actually use
If less than half the intended size is filled and price has already moved through my invalidation, I cancel the rest and manage what I have as a reduced-size trade — or flatten if the thesis is gone. I do not average in to “complete” the ticket. Completing size after the move is a new decision, not the original one.

If the partial is tiny noise (a few percent) and the level still holds, I may leave a working residual with a hard time stop. That time stop is pre-set; I don’t extend it because I’m annoyed.

Weekly review: I sort the journal by partial = yes and ask whether those tickets had worse expectancy than clean fills. Usually they do when I chase the remainder. Curious how others tag partials so the review isn’t just vibes.

Re: Partial fills on XAUUSD: how I log them and when I cancel the rest

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2026 1:05 am
by PropScalpDesk
Partial fills: cancel and log, do not spam

On XAUUSD especially, partial fills are normal under speed. My rule is dull and it has saved me from worse average prices more times than clever order tricks ever did.
  • If a partial prints and the remainder hangs: cancel the rest after a short fixed wait in seconds, pre-set before the session.
  • Do not fire repeated market orders to “complete the size.”
  • Log partial rate by session — if it spikes, size down or stand aside.
  • Manage the filled piece with the original invalidation, or scratch if the idea required full size to make sense after costs.
Chasing remainder is how a clean A-setup becomes a cost pile. From a Frankfurt desk, gold speed without a cancel rule is just volunteering for slippage.

I also note whether partials cluster on one broker path or one VPS route. If partial rate jumps after an infrastructure change, I treat it as a path problem before I blame gold itself. Measure first, then adjust size.

How long do you wait on a working remainder before cancel — and is it a written number, or a feeling in the moment?

Re: Partial fills on XAUUSD: how I log them and when I cancel the rest

Posted: Sat Oct 17, 2026 12:01 am
by Shadow Trader
PropScalpDesk asked for a written number, so here is mine: 4 seconds on gold, then the remainder is cancelled without a second look. I got there from an older stretch of my journal, back when I let remainders work and logged how long each one took to complete.

There were 52 partial tickets in that sample. The 35 that completed within 4 seconds averaged a small positive result, while the 17 that needed longer averaged around minus 0.3R, because a slow remainder usually means price is already leaving.
img_12343_r1.png
img_12343_r1.png (63.12 KiB) Viewed 100 times
The chart splits those 52 tickets by how long the remainder took and shows the average result for each group. The drop after the 4 second mark was sharper than I expected.

On LondonScalper's question about tagging, I log fill percentage in bands rather than a yes or no. Under 25 percent, 25 to 75, and over 75 behave quite differently, and a single partial tag blends them into one mushy average.

One edge case I still argue with myself about is a residual that fills just as price comes back to my entry. Is that still the original trade, or a fresh decision that deserves its own tag?

Re: Partial fills on XAUUSD: how I log them and when I cancel the rest

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:54 am
by Shadow Trader
Something my log showed that I had not expected is how much the partial rate depends on ticket size. Below 1 lot on XAUUSD I almost never saw one, while tickets of 3 lots or more filled in pieces on about one entry in five during the London to New York handoff.

So part of the fix sits upstream of any cancel rule. I send the full 3 lots only when the book looks normal, and on thin afternoons I size down to 1.5 lots and accept the smaller trade.

Some platforms also let you choose the fill policy. With immediate or cancel set on the order, the unfilled part is dropped by the broker straight away, which takes the waiting decision out of my hands altogether.

The catch is that it also drops the remainder on a fast move in my favour, which is exactly when I would have liked the full size. On my numbers that was the smaller cost, though I can see a scalper with a wider stop deciding the other way.

PropScalpDesk's point about infrastructure matched my experience too. My partial rate roughly doubled for a week after a VPS move, and it settled again once the provider changed the route.

Re: Partial fills on XAUUSD: how I log them and when I cancel the rest

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2026 6:54 am
by Shadow Trader
Retail traders often assume an order either fills fully or not at all. In fast or thin markets, partial fills are possible. A request for five lots might return three lots at one price and two at a worse price, or three lots filled and two cancelled.

Platforms handle this in different ways. Some show a single averaged position, hiding the details. Others record separate deals within the order history. The fill policy, such as fill-or-kill, immediate-or-cancel, or return, determines what happens to the unfilled remainder.

For scalpers, partial fills distort risk calculations. A stop loss sized for five lots might apply to only three, or the average entry price may differ from the screen price used to compute risk-reward. Reviewing the deal history, not just the position summary, reveals the true entry. Where available, selecting a fill policy that matches the strategy removes ambiguity. Immediate-or-cancel suits strategies that prefer no fill over a poor fill.