Page 1 of 1

Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Sat Sep 12, 2026 8:32 pm
by LondonScalper
Process note for the first 90 minutes of London — not a signal thread.

I run a simple three-strike rule. A strike is not a losing trade. A strike is a process breach: chasing after a miss, taking a setup outside my pre-marked levels, or overriding a news blackout because “it looks clean.”

How I count it
1. Strike one — note it, keep size normal, tighten the checklist for the next ticket.
2. Strike two — size down to half for the rest of the open window.
3. Strike three — flat for the remainder of that London open. No “one more.”

Why it works for me: early London is where my edge is supposed to live. If I’m already bending rules by 08:30, I’m not trading a playbook — I’m negotiating with myself. The rule removes the negotiation.

What I do not count as a strike
A clean setup that stops out. Bad fills on an otherwise valid ticket. Standing aside when spread spikes. Those are costs of doing business, not discipline failures.

I write the three strikes on a sticky before the open so I’m not inventing the rule after the second mistake. If you’ve got a similar hard stop for the session, how do you define a strike versus a normal loss?

Re: Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2026 12:48 am
by PropScalpDesk
Three strikes and the open is done

I use a three-strike rule on the European and London open so a messy first hour cannot become a messy day. Ending conditions are as important as entry conditions when you trade for a living.

Strike examples that count for me:
  • Full R loser.
  • Two partials that net to roughly minus R after costs.
  • Rule break — moved stop, chased, ignored spread filter — automatic strike even if profit and loss survived.
Hit three → flatten, close platform, review later. Not switch to gold. Not “try New York.” The open gets a budget of mistakes; it does not get unlimited retries. That rule has saved more weeks than any clever trigger I have tested.

Strikes reset next session, not after a short walk. If I could clear strikes with a stretch break, the rule would be worthless. The open budget is daily. Spend it carefully or go do something unpaid on purpose.

What counts as a strike in your book — and do rule breaks cost a strike even on winners?

Re: Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 8:45 am
by Fairman
PropScalpDesk wrote: Two partials that net to roughly minus R after costs.
Two different definitions in here and I think the gap matters. LondonScalper doesn't count a clean stop or a bad fill as a strike, only process breaches, while you count outcomes too. What made you include them? One argument for it: a strike rule based only on breaches relies on judging your own breaches honestly at 08:40, which is exactly when that judgment is weakest, and a loss is harder to argue with. The argument against is that a few clean losers can end a good open early. Have you compared how often each version would have stopped you on mornings that ended up fine?

Re: Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Fri Oct 16, 2026 11:01 pm
by Shadow Trader
Fairman's question made me go back through my last 40 London opens and replay the setups I logged after each would-be third strike. I scored three versions: LondonScalper's breaches only, PropScalpDesk's breaches plus losers, and a middle one where a clean loser counts as half a strike.
img_12342_r1.png
img_12342_r1.png (45.44 KiB) Viewed 98 times
The chart has the counts. Breaches only would have ended 7 of the 40 opens, and on 2 of those the trades I skipped would have netted positive. Counting losers ended 15 opens, 8 of which turned out fine, so more than half of those stops cost me a decent morning.

The half strike version stopped 10 opens with 4 false alarms. That is where I have settled, because Fairman is right that judging your own breaches at 08:40 is shaky, and a loser at least cannot be argued away.

One caveat on my own numbers. The skipped trades come from my notes, and I suspect I log setups more generously when I am not allowed to take them, so the false alarm counts are probably a little high.

Does anyone count a partial as half a strike as well? Or does that get too fiddly to track live during the open?

Re: Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:15 am
by Shadow Trader
One pattern in the same 40 opens surprised me more than the version comparison. Counting breaches only, I reached a second strike on 11 mornings, and 7 of those went on to a third, most of them within 20 minutes of the second.

Half size at strike two, as LondonScalper describes, seems to be part of the reason. A half size ticket felt cheap, so I took setups I would have passed on at full size, and the third strike was usually one of those.

So my strike two rule now depends on the clock. Before 08:45 London a second strike means the open is over, while later in the window it means half size and a maximum of one more trade.

The early cut costs something on paper. On 2 of the mornings it would have ended early, the remaining setups netted positive, though I suspect that is the same generous logging I mentioned before.

I also keep the tally on paper rather than in my head. Each strike is a line on the sticky note, written the moment it happens, because by 09:00 I am remarkably bad at remembering whether the chase at 08:20 was one strike or two.

Re: Three-strike rule for the London open: when I stop taking setups

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2026 12:34 pm
by Shadow Trader
FX options have an expiry cut, the moment at which an option is settled against the prevailing spot rate. The New York 10am cut is the most widely followed, with the Tokyo cut also relevant for yen pairs. Large expiries are commonly published by banks and data vendors as strike levels with notional amounts.

Clustering happens because option strikes concentrate at round numbers such as 1.1000 or 150.00. Near expiry, dealers who hedge these positions dynamically may buy or sell spot to stay neutral, which can dampen movement near a large strike. This is often described as pinning, where price gravitates toward a level into the cut.

The effect is strongest when the notional is large relative to normal liquidity, when spot is already close to the strike, and when no major news is pending. It is weak or absent when macro data, central bank commentary or a strong trend dominates.

After the cut, the hedging demand disappears, and price can move freely again, sometimes with an abrupt pickup in volatility. For scalpers, the sensible approach is to treat expiry levels as areas of possible compression, not as reliable magnets. Published expiry lists are also incomplete, so conviction should stay modest.