Page 4 of 4

Re: Revenge Trading Is the #1 Account Killer

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2026 8:12 pm
by PropScalpDesk
PTScalper wrote:A mandatory pause requires both mechanics and cognition to be effective. Time alone does not break tilt; a trader can easily spend five minutes simply brewing a more aggressive revenge plan.
Agreed — the hybrid is the useful part. Five minutes of detachment metabolises the spike; the written sentence is what proves the prefrontal cortex is back online. From this Frankfurt desk I treat that sentence as a soft gate, not theatre. If it contains recover, make back, or deserve, the session soft-stops before the firm's hard daily loss ever enters the picture.

Desk rule: after any process-dirty loser I step away for five minutes, then write one calm thesis line. No sentence, or a repair sentence, means no new risk until the next session open. Chart colour changes and script blockers are optional furniture; they do not replace the written gate when the urge is still repair.

On prop accounts this matters more than on personal capital. The hard stop is the cliff; the personal soft-stop is the guardrail. I would rather log a flat afternoon tagged tilt_pause than invent a second ticket to feel engaged.

Do you keep the written sentence in the journal only, or do you also require a second person / checklist tick before the ticket unlocks?

Re: Revenge Trading Is the #1 Account Killer

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 10:23 am
by Fairman
PropScalpDesk wrote: What is your mandatory pause — fixed minutes, or until you can write the next setup in one calm sentence?
Until I can write the next setup in one sentence without 'back' in it, as in 'get it back'. Usually takes 10 or 15 minutes.

Re: Revenge Trading Is the #1 Account Killer

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 2:22 pm
by LondonNewsTrader
PTScalper wrote: It tracks your daily drawdown (your prop firm soft stop) and triggers a time-based lockout after any recorded loss, completely preventing the "immediate size-up" spiral.
A couple of parts of the script don't do what the description says.

maxRiskSize is declared as an input but never used anywhere in the code. Position size comes from default_qty_type = strategy.percent_of_equity with a value of 1, which means each position's notional value is 1 percent of equity, not that 1 percent is at risk. On a leveraged FX chart those are very different numbers, so nothing actually prevents sizing up.

The cooldown is compared against bar times. On a 15-minute chart the next bar opens at least 15 minutes after the previous one, so a 5-minute cooldown can never block an entry there. It only has an effect on charts of five minutes or less. Either set the default in bars, or make it at least one bar on whatever timeframe the script is running.

The soft stop logic is fine. I'd add the exit and entry time windows around scheduled releases as another condition for masterClear, since that is when the revenge urge usually starts.

Re: Revenge Trading Is the #1 Account Killer

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 12:49 pm
by PropScalpDesk
The sentence test is good — no “get it back” allowed. Ten or fifteen minutes is about what I need before the next ticket is a decision again rather than a repair job.

Revenge feels like determination. It is not.

Re: Revenge Trading Is the #1 Account Killer

Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2026 10:12 am
by FXS Prop Desk
Time-boxed series with breaks are a structured way to manage chronic stress. A practical guideline some traders follow: the length of the break should increase with the intensity of the series. For example, after a three-week high-volume series, a full week off; after a lighter series, a few days.

A useful extra is to plan activities for the breaks, so the time off is restful rather than spent watching charts without trading.