Re: Plotting win rate against reward to risk for each setup, and what the picture showed
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:12 pm
Agreed, and the same logic is why we stopped ranking setups by the gap to the curve. What also matters is how many trades each point is built on. A setup at 35% and 2.2R with only 40 trades has a standard error on the win rate of about 7.5 points, which is twice the 3.75 point cushion, so it may not be above break even at all.
A practical version: plot each setup with a horizontal error bar on the win rate (roughly square root of p times 1 minus p over n). Setups whose bar crosses the curve go on watch, not into the live plan. It makes the chart less exciting but much more honest.
A practical version: plot each setup with a horizontal error bar on the win rate (roughly square root of p times 1 minus p over n). Setups whose bar crosses the curve go on watch, not into the live plan. It makes the chart less exciting but much more honest.