Page 2 of 2

Re: Forex scalping EURUSD London sesion - Judas Swing

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:43 am
by Shadow Trader
Draw a box around the first 15 minutes after London open and a fake move shows up on about half the mornings. Of course it does. Price has to go somewhere, and if the first push is a coin flip, it reverses roughly half the time.

That's the weak spot in the Judas swing idea. The story says London opens around 08:00 GMT (09:00 WAT in winter), sweeps the Asian high or low to grab stops, then delivers the real move the other way. Looks great on a hand-picked screenshot. Pulled from 100 random mornings, it gets a lot muddier.

Then there's the definition problem. How far past the Asian range counts as a sweep? 3 pips, 10 pips, a close back inside the box? Change the rule and the hit rate changes with it. Plenty of traders fit the rule to the chart after the fact without noticing.

None of this means the open is quiet or random. Spreads settle, liquidity floods in, and early stops do get run, often in both directions on the same morning. The idea isn't useless. The certainty wrapped around it is.

A fair test is dull. Pick one pair, mark the Asian range the same way every day for three months, and log what the first 15 minutes did, no cherry-picking.

Does the reversal still show up as often as the screenshots suggest once the log is complete, or does it melt into noise on your pair?