Advertisement IC Markets

Trade Duration: What Holding Time Says About Your Habits

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Trade Duration: What Holding Time Says About Your Habits

Post by Shadow Trader »

FXS Prop Desk's two or three times rule is sensible, though I would size it from the spread of winning durations rather than the average alone. Durations are lopsided, with most trades finishing quickly and a few slow ones pulling the mean up.

Say 40 trades hit their target, with a median of 18 minutes and a mean of 24. Twice the mean gives a 48 minute limit, and in this made up sample only 4 of the 40 winners took longer than that.
img_13235_r2.png
img_13235_r2.png (61.68 KiB) Viewed 69 times
The chart shows that spread, with the 48 minute line cutting off the slow tail. Three times the mean, 72 minutes, would keep 3 of those 4 but gives every stalled loser another 24 minutes to drift.

The more useful check is what the trades still open at the limit went on to do. If most of them ended at the stop, the limit is saving money, and if most still reached target, it is cutting winners the way early manual exits do.

That second case links back to the split between target hits and hand closed winners. A time limit only makes sense when it is built from trades that were allowed to run.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Trade Duration: What Holding Time Says About Your Habits

Post by Shadow Trader »

Most strategies exit on price, through stops and targets. A time-based exit closes the position after a fixed duration, regardless of price. For scalpers, whose edge may exist only over a short horizon, time exits can be surprisingly effective.

The logic is that some signals have a limited lifespan. A momentum burst may carry for ten seconds and then decay. Holding beyond that window exposes the trade to noise without any remaining edge.

Testing involves measuring average return as a function of holding time. Plotting profit per trade against minutes held shows where the edge peaks and fades. Exits placed near the peak capture most of the available move. Combining a time exit with a protective stop often works well, with the stop guarding against sudden adverse movement and the time limit ensuring capital is freed. Reviewing exit statistics regularly confirms whether the optimal duration remains stable or shifts with market conditions.
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Trade Duration: What Holding Time Says About Your Habits

Post by Fairman »

Comparing the average duration of winners and losers over forty trades is a quick one and it caught me out. Mine came out at 4 minutes for winners and 11 for losers. So I was cutting profits fast and letting losses breathe, which is the opposite of what I thought I did.

The outlier check is the sharper tool though. One trade I'd left running for most of an afternoon because "it must come back" lost 3.2R, which was nearly a fifth of my month's total losses. Looking at it in the list, it was easy to see, but it never stood out on the chart.

The rule I use now is a time stop. If a trade hasn't hit 0.5R in 15 minutes on M5, I close it at market. On a 0.5 lot trade with an 8 pip stop, that's usually a loss of 2 to 3 pips, around 12 dollars, instead of the full 40 dollar stop. The downside is that a few of those would have turned into winners. In my test, about 1 in 6 did, and the rest saved money.

Do you apply a duration limit to winners too, or only to losers? And what would you do about a trade that sits near breakeven for ages?
It’s Fairman :geek:
Post Reply