Page 2 of 2

Re: MAE and MFE: Two Numbers That Reveal How Your Trades Really Behave

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2026 6:07 pm
by FXS HongKong Scalper
The MAE and MFE tracking is very useful. One thing to check is how the script handles the bar where the trade is opened. If the entry is in the middle of a bar, using that bar's full high and low will show an excursion that happened before the trade existed. Starting the tracking from the next bar, or using a lower timeframe for the entry bar, gives cleaner numbers. That matters most for scalps, where the first bar can make up a large part of the total excursion.

Re: MAE and MFE: Two Numbers That Reveal How Your Trades Really Behave

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:27 am
by Fairman
Starting with a rough estimate from chart review is realistic, because most of us don't have software that logs it. I do it in a spreadsheet with four columns: entry, worst point against, best point in favour, exit. It takes about thirty seconds a trade if I fill it in when I close, and a lot longer if I leave it for the weekend, so I do it straight away.

The example that opened my eyes was a loser with 15 pips of MFE on a 12 pip stop. It had been 1.25R in profit and I let it turn into a full -1R. On 0.5 lots, that's 75 dollars of open profit turning into a 60 dollar loss, a swing of 135 dollars. That made me look at how many of my losers did the same, and it was 22 out of 70, or 31 percent. Not tiny.

On winners, a typical MAE is less than 40 percent of the stop, as the post says. My own median is 3 pips on a 10 pip stop. So there is some room to tighten, though I'd rather use the room for a better entry price than a narrower stop.

The thirty to forty trades per setup is where I get stuck, because some setups only show up twice a week. Do you merge similar setups to reach the sample, or just wait? And do you track the numbers per pair too?