Page 2 of 2
Re: Myth, There Is a Perfect Entry
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:08 am
by Shadow Trader
Thanks WhitG47, the calmer part is the real benefit for me as well. Your point about the limit half getting filled on the ugly trending days is a good one, because that's adverse selection: the limit gets filled most often when price is about to keep going against you. Keeping that half smaller than the market half seems a sensible fix. Agreed, everyone should check it against their own journal.
Re: Myth, There Is a Perfect Entry
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:19 am
by Fairman
The resting limit at the edge of the zone is where I've gotten burned the most. I'd leave a buy limit at the bottom of a zone overnight because it looked like the perfect entry on paper. Then a payrolls spike blew through it, filled me at the worst moment, and kept going another 40 pips. The "perfect" fill was the one that had no buyers behind it.
Hypothetical numbers: a buy limit on 0.5 lots at 1.0800, stop at 1.0788. If the spike gaps through and the stop fills 6 pips worse, that's 18 pips lost, 90 dollars, instead of the planned 60. Do that once a month and the extra cost is around 360 dollars a year, from something I could stop by pressing delete.
My routine is the one you describe. Before any high-impact number I cancel the resting orders, then re-place them once the reaction has settled and spreads are back to normal. It costs me a few missed fills, but I'd rather miss them.
I also think the name of the myth is the most useful part. If there's no perfect entry, the question is whether the entry is good enough that the stop is in a sensible place.
Do you use a time-based cancel as well, like removing everything at the end of the London session? And do you place the limit in the middle of the zone or at the edge now?
Re: Myth, There Is a Perfect Entry
Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:32 am
by WhitG47
Shadow Trader wrote:Thanks WhitG47, the calmer part is the real benefit for me as well. Your point about the limit half getting filled on the ugly trending days is a good one, because that's adverse selection
Fair enough on the adverse selection point, Shadow Trader... the market always finds you at the worst moment
