Page 2 of 2

Re: Debt and Trading, A Dangerous Combination

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2026 6:59 pm
by gwhitlock64
PTScalper wrote:How long do you trade and where are you come from if i may ask?
Yeah, pretty much never ending, tbh, and you're right that it only really suits once you've got a style sorted. I'm in Staffordshire, near Stafford, and I've been at it about six years, on and off. Your fixed blocks probably beat my tripwire for stress, mind, as mine only kicks in once I've already made a mess of things... I do put the week off in the diary now so I dont talk myself back in early.

Re: Debt and Trading, A Dangerous Combination

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2026 11:51 pm
by PTScalper
gwhitlock64 wrote: Sun Oct 25, 2026 6:59 pm
PTScalper wrote:How long do you trade and where are you come from if i may ask?
Yeah, pretty much never ending, tbh, and you're right that it only really suits once you've got a style sorted. I'm in Staffordshire, near Stafford, and I've been at it about six years, on and off. Your fixed blocks probably beat my tripwire for stress, mind, as mine only kicks in once I've already made a mess of things... I do put the week off in the diary now so I dont talk myself back in early.
Cool, i was not in your city, but in UK i was in London, Leeds, Manchester and Huddersfield. In London i love Canary Wharf, Especially in winter.

Yeah cool mind and handle stress well is one of key aspekt of forex trading. I found out, that more that half of my trading rules are based to cool head and handle stress.

Btw i have traded 18+ years forex spot markets.

Re: Debt and Trading, A Dangerous Combination

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 7:58 am
by Shadow Trader
Give an optimiser enough knobs, such as the moving average length, the RSI threshold, the stop size and the session hours, and it will find a combination that made a fortune in the past. That combination probably captured noise, not signal.

Signs of overfitting:

1. Many parameters relative to the number of trades.

2. Results that collapse when a parameter is nudged slightly.

3. A very specific setting, like an RSI threshold of 27.3, doing far better than 27 or 28.

4. Profits concentrated in a handful of lucky trades.

5. No logical reason why the rule should work.

A robust strategy tends to show a plateau: a wide range of parameter values produce similar, decent results. A fragile one shows a spike at a single combination.

Practical defences include keeping the parameter count low, testing on data from different periods and pairs, and demanding a clear rationale for each rule.

How many parameters does the current strategy have, and does performance degrade gracefully when they change?

Re: Debt and Trading, A Dangerous Combination

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:51 pm
by FXS Prop Desk
gwhitlock64 wrote: For me the better test is whether you can shrug off the loss without chasing it
That's a better test, and harder to fake. The "without changing your daily life" rule covers the money side, while yours covers behaviour, and behaviour is where most of the damage happens. The catch is that nobody knows in advance whether they'll chase, so the money rule is the one that can be checked before the first trade. The two work together: size the account so a total loss wouldn't touch daily life, then treat any urge to win a loss back quickly as the signal to stop, which is pretty much the tripwire you described to PTScalper.