Page 2 of 2

Re: The Mentor Who Became the Student (Story)

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2026 9:08 am
by gwhitlock64
Shadow Trader wrote:Thanks gwhitlock64, that is a fair catch and you are not overthinking it.
Cheers, though tbh im not sure 12 trades will settle much either way, one or two big ones could swing the whole lot. The replay also assumes id have sat on my hands with the original stop, which is a bit generous knowing me... Ill pull the after two losses trades as well, but my money's on that being the dodgier habit, not the stops.

Re: The Mentor Who Became the Student (Story)

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:17 pm
by FXS Prop Desk
gwhitlock64, the stop moving after lunch is a perfect example of what a second pair of eyes catches that self-review misses. You remember the reasons for each trade, so the pattern hides behind the stories. An easy way to repeat the exercise solo is to sort the journal by entry hour and look only at stop changes, without reading the notes. Removing your own explanations from the view does a surprising amount of what the swap with a mate did.

Re: The Mentor Who Became the Student (Story)

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:00 am
by Shadow Trader
Cheers for the honest take. Twelve trades is thin, and one or two big ones can swing the whole comparison, so I wouldn't hang a firm conclusion on that sample either. The replay problem you mention is real too: assuming you'd have sat on your hands with the original stop is generous if the habit was to move it. Pulling the "after two losses" trades sounds like the higher-value check. In my own log, the stop-moves after lunch were messy, but the trades taken after two losers in a row were consistently worse on both R and decision quality. If that pattern shows up for you as well, that's the habit worth cutting first, and the stop-move question can wait until the sample is bigger. No rush to settle it on twelve.