Page 2 of 2
Re: How prop firm spreads differ from IC Markets raw
Posted: Fri Oct 16, 2026 12:11 pm
by FXS Prop Desk
The all-in method is the right way to compare: a raw spread of 0.0 plus $7 round-turn commission works out to about 0.7 pips on EURUSD. For fairness, prop pricing isn't uniform. Some firms run their own pricing with markups, others pass through a broker's raw feed with commission, and the difference between firms can be larger than between prop and retail.
Readers comparing can log the spread on both platforms at the same minutes (London open, 10:00, NY open, 16:00 London) for a week. Five or six readings a day over a week tells you more than any marketing page, especially around the transition periods where padding tends to show up.
Re: How prop firm spreads differ from IC Markets raw
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2026 6:40 am
by Shadow Trader
Converting commission to pips is simple on EURUSD, where a pip on one lot is worth 10 dollars and 7 dollars round turn is 0.7 pips. Where the pip is not priced in dollars the same commission comes out differently, which matters once the sheet covers several pairs.
One lot of USDJPY moves 1,000 yen per pip, so at 150 it is worth about 6.67 dollars and 7 dollars of commission is about 1.05 pips. On EURGBP the pip is 10 pounds, so with GBPUSD at 1.30 it is worth 13 dollars and the same 7 dollars is about 0.54 pips.
So a zero spread account with a fixed commission is relatively cheaper on EURGBP and dearer on USDJPY than the EURUSD figure suggests. The all in cost column needs that conversion per pair.
The server time point in the scripts needs care too. British and American clocks shift a week apart in autumn, so where the server clock follows US daylight saving, a killzone set in server hours sits an hour off London for that week.
Logging the killzone in London time and converting it each session avoids that. Comparing the same minutes on both feeds only works if they really are the same minutes.
Re: How prop firm spreads differ from IC Markets raw
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:34 am
by Shadow Trader
Many prop firms provide simulated accounts, with fills generated by the firm's system, not real markets. Funded traders may be paid from a share of simulated profits, with execution details varying by provider.
Simulated environments can differ from live trading in slippage, spread, and rejection behavior. Some are more generous, offering instant fills at quoted prices. Others apply conservative models that add costs. A strategy refined in one simulation may behave differently in another or in a real account.
Scalpers should test execution quality on the firm's platform just as they would with a broker, measuring slippage and fill speed. Rules prohibiting certain strategies, such as latency arbitrage or exploiting simulation quirks, may apply, and violations can lead to account termination. Understanding what the firm does with trades, whether it hedges them in the real market or operates internally, offers insight into incentives. Selecting firms with transparent practices and a record of paying traders reduces risk.