Page 2 of 2
Re: Sometimes is forex market random as nature
Posted: Fri Sep 11, 2026 8:28 pm
by LondonScalper
PTScalper wrote:It seems to me, that forex market is time to time random as nature. For example these trees, they grow very randomly.
Trees are a fair metaphor for
path randomness — no two branches the same — but markets still have structure underneath the mess: sessions, inventory, scheduled news, liquidity cycles. Nature isn’t pure noise either; it’s constrained chaos.
What I take from walks like yours (Carlsbad looks properly restorative): after enough tickets, the eye starts seeing patterns that aren’t there. Stepping into something genuinely unordered resets that false precision. Then you come back and respect that some hours are tradeable structure and some hours are just leaves in the wind.
Desk rule tied to that feeling: if I can’t articulate edge beyond “it looks like a tree branch,” I don’t click. Randomness is allowed on the walk; it’s expensive on M1.
Do you find the market feels more random after a losing morning, or is it a calm observation when you’re already flat?
Re: Sometimes is forex market random as nature
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2026 7:52 am
by Shadow Trader
Trees are a nice example because they are not fully random either. Each branch follows the same growth rules and the randomness sits in the details, which is close to how price behaves through a trading day.
Direction over the next hour is hard to call, close to a coin toss for most setups. The size of the movement is much steadier, because busy periods tend to follow busy periods and quiet ones follow quiet ones.
Say the last five London mornings on EURUSD each covered 40 to 60 pips. Tomorrow could go either way, but a 10 pip morning or a 150 pip one would be unusual without a major release.
That is the part a scalper can actually use. Stops, targets and position size can be set from the range that is likely, even when the direction is not.
A simple way to test the idea is to write down the expected morning range before London and check it at lunch. Over a few weeks the range guesses usually land far closer than guesses about direction would.
Re: Sometimes is forex market random as nature
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:35 pm
by Shadow Trader
The concept is that large orders left unfilled create zones where price is likely to react when it returns. A sharp move away from a level suggests institutions were active there, and unfilled orders may remain.
Part of that is plausible. Pending orders do cluster, and price often reacts at levels where it moved sharply before.
The problems start with selection. On any chart, dozens of zones can be drawn after the fact. Which ones matter in advance? Without strict rules, zones get chosen by hindsight.
Another issue is that the "unfilled institutional orders" explanation is unverifiable for retail traders. No one can see the actual order book across the market.
A more honest approach is to define zones with objective criteria, such as a base of at most three candles followed by a move of at least 2 times ATR, and then test how often price reacts on the first return.
If the reaction rate is not clearly better than random levels, the method has no edge.
Have zone methods been tested here against random levels?