Advertisement IC Markets

Edgewonk, Excel or Notion for a scalping journal?

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
FXS London Scalper
Posts: 1046
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm

Edgewonk, Excel or Notion for a scalping journal?

Post by FXS London Scalper »

I've used all three over the last two years, so here's a comparison for anyone choosing.

Edgewonk
  • Plus: built for trading. Imports from MT4/MT5, ready statistics, tagging, and charts of mistakes.
  • Minus: paid, and the structure is fixed. For very custom metrics, it's limited.
Excel / Google Sheets
  • Plus: total flexibility. I can calculate cost per trade, R-multiples, session splits, anything.
  • Minus: everything has to be built. Imports need formatting. Screenshots don't fit naturally.
Notion
  • Plus: great for notes, screenshots, and reviews. A database per trade with linked weekly reviews works well.
  • Minus: weak for numbers. Formulas are clumsy, charts need workarounds.
What I use now: Excel for numbers (MT5 export, one sheet), Notion for review notes and screenshots of selected trades only, not every trade. Edgewonk I dropped because I spent more time adjusting tags than reviewing.

For a scalper with many trades, automatic import matters most. Typing 20 trades a day by hand is how journals die.

What do you use, and what made you stick with it?
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5744
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Edgewonk, Excel or Notion for a scalping journal?

Post by Shadow Trader »

This is a helpful comparison. One consideration for anyone choosing is how much time the journal will take to maintain day to day. A scalper who takes many trades per session can easily end up spending as long on journaling as on trading, and a tool that requires manual entry for every field will quickly be abandoned.

That probably favours tools with import features for the raw trade data, combined with a simple manual layer for the things only the trader can record, such as the setup name, whether the rules were followed, and a short note. The automated part handles the numbers, and the manual part handles the judgement.

The split you describe, numbers in a spreadsheet and notes elsewhere, makes sense for that reason. The main risk is that the two drift apart over time if trades are not linked by a common identifier. Using the platform's ticket number in both places is a simple way to keep them connected.

For anyone starting out, it might be worth beginning with a very basic spreadsheet and only moving to a more complex tool once it is clear which statistics are actually being used. Many people set up dozens of metrics and end up looking at three of them. Knowing which ones matter before paying for a tool avoids that.

Screenshots are the other question. A screenshot of every trade is useful but builds up fast. Saving them only for trades that broke a rule or were unusually good or bad keeps the collection manageable and focused on the cases worth reviewing.

What statistics do people here find they actually look at regularly in their journal?
Post Reply