Comparing prop firms usually starts with price and profit split. For scalpers, other rules matter more.
Proposed comparison columns:
- Minimum hold time.
- News trading policy (window, which events).
- Max lot size per trade/symbol.
- Commission per lot.
- Typical spread on EURUSD during London (measured, not advertised).
- Daily loss calculation (balance/equity, reset time).
- Max drawdown type (static/trailing).
- Consistency rules.
- Weekend holding.
- EA allowed?
- Copy trading allowed?
- Platform (MT5, cTrader, proprietary).
Rows: one per firm, with data from the terms and members' own measurements.
Keep it factual, link to the terms where possible, and note the date of each entry because rules change.
Would members help build this? Which columns would you add?
A prop firm comparison sheet: the rules that matter to scalpers
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 1101
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
A prop firm comparison sheet: the rules that matter to scalpers
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5944
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: A prop firm comparison sheet: the rules that matter to scalpers
This is a good set of columns. A couple of things I would suggest adding for scalpers specifically.
One is a column for how the firm treats very short holding times. Minimum hold time is listed, but some firms do not have a fixed minimum and instead have a general rule about "exploiting" fast price feeds or latency. That wording can be applied to scalping in a way that is hard to predict. Noting whether such a clause exists, and how it is worded, would help people judge the risk.
Another is the stop-out and margin level. Scalpers sometimes run larger positions for short periods, and if the leverage on the account is lower than on a retail account, margin can become a constraint before the risk rules do.
A third is commission per round turn versus per side, because firms do not always state it the same way, and the difference doubles the cost figure if it is misread.
For the measured spread column, it would help to agree on a method. For example, the median spread on EURUSD sampled every minute between a fixed start and end time on a normal day without major releases. Otherwise contributions will be measured differently and not really comparable.
The date on each entry is important, as you say. Rules at prop firms change often enough that a sheet older than a few months could be misleading. A "last checked" column might be clearer than a single date for the row.
If the sheet goes ahead, it might be worth adding a note on which items come from the terms and which come from members' own measurements, so readers can weigh them accordingly.
One is a column for how the firm treats very short holding times. Minimum hold time is listed, but some firms do not have a fixed minimum and instead have a general rule about "exploiting" fast price feeds or latency. That wording can be applied to scalping in a way that is hard to predict. Noting whether such a clause exists, and how it is worded, would help people judge the risk.
Another is the stop-out and margin level. Scalpers sometimes run larger positions for short periods, and if the leverage on the account is lower than on a retail account, margin can become a constraint before the risk rules do.
A third is commission per round turn versus per side, because firms do not always state it the same way, and the difference doubles the cost figure if it is misread.
For the measured spread column, it would help to agree on a method. For example, the median spread on EURUSD sampled every minute between a fixed start and end time on a normal day without major releases. Otherwise contributions will be measured differently and not really comparable.
The date on each entry is important, as you say. Rules at prop firms change often enough that a sheet older than a few months could be misleading. A "last checked" column might be clearer than a single date for the row.
If the sheet goes ahead, it might be worth adding a note on which items come from the terms and which come from members' own measurements, so readers can weigh them accordingly.
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2399
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: A prop firm comparison sheet: the rules that matter to scalpers
This sheet would be genuinely useful, especially if the measured spread column has a fixed method behind it. Sampling the EURUSD spread at set times, say the first hour of London and the New York overlap, on a normal day without major releases, makes the numbers comparable between firms instead of mixing quiet and news conditions.
A couple of columns worth adding for scalpers: whether there is a minimum number of trading days, and how the firm treats trades opened and closed within a few seconds, since some terms ban that under wording about latency or tick scalping. Another is whether the daily loss limit includes open floating losses and commissions, because that changes how much room you really have on a busy morning. Slippage rules on stops during news could also sit next to the news policy.
On upkeep, a last-checked date per row plus a link to the exact clause in the terms keeps it honest. Rules get rewritten quietly, so stale rows are worse than empty ones, and flagging anything older than a few months as needing review would keep the sheet trustworthy.
A couple of columns worth adding for scalpers: whether there is a minimum number of trading days, and how the firm treats trades opened and closed within a few seconds, since some terms ban that under wording about latency or tick scalping. Another is whether the daily loss limit includes open floating losses and commissions, because that changes how much room you really have on a busy morning. Slippage rules on stops during news could also sit next to the news policy.
On upkeep, a last-checked date per row plus a link to the exact clause in the terms keeps it honest. Rules get rewritten quietly, so stale rows are worse than empty ones, and flagging anything older than a few months as needing review would keep the sheet trustworthy.