The third setup before lunch is the one I have to justify the hardest, and I usually can't. Two scratches before noon is my cap, even if the next chart looks cleaner than the first two.
A scratch, for me, is a stopped trade or a scratch-out around break-even after I was wrong enough to want out. Two of those already used the morning. On a $10,000 account that can be $40 and another $40, or $40 and a $12 scratch, but the count is two attempts, not only the dollars. The schematic is a morning with a 16-pip EURUSD short at 1.08640, stop 1.08800, 0.25 lot, $40, that gets stopped, a second try on the same pair that gets out around -$8, and a third, genuinely tidy gap at the London lunch edge. I still don't take the third. The day is already noisy, and the third trade is where I start making it back before lunch.
I write the cap in the journal before the session, not after the second loss when I feel like negotiating. If I only took one trade and it scratched, I still have one attempt left. The cap is two, not two plus a bonus because the third one is gold.
Two scratches before noon is my cap, even if a third setup looks cleaner
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2144
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Two scratches before noon is my cap, even if a third setup looks cleaner
Setting the cap before the session is the part that makes this work. A rule decided after two losses is really a negotiation, and the mind is very good at finding reasons why the next chart is the exception. Counting attempts rather than just dollars also catches something the P&L hides: two scratches usually mean the read on the market is off for that morning, whether the conditions are choppy, the range is too tight, or the bias is simply wrong.
The cleaner-looking third setup is exactly the trap. After two failed attempts, setups tend to look better than they are because there is a quiet wish to repair the morning. Lunch on London is also typically thinner, so spreads and follow-through are often worse right when the temptation peaks.
One thing worth reviewing in the journal is whether skipped third setups would actually have paid over a few months. If they mostly would not have, the cap is protecting the account. If they often would have, the cap might still be worth keeping for discipline reasons, but it is useful to know the real cost rather than assume it.
The cleaner-looking third setup is exactly the trap. After two failed attempts, setups tend to look better than they are because there is a quiet wish to repair the morning. Lunch on London is also typically thinner, so spreads and follow-through are often worse right when the temptation peaks.
One thing worth reviewing in the journal is whether skipped third setups would actually have paid over a few months. If they mostly would not have, the cap is protecting the account. If they often would have, the cap might still be worth keeping for discipline reasons, but it is useful to know the real cost rather than assume it.