Every few weeks a spreadsheet shows up with 1% a day turning $1,000 into something huge. It always looks great.
Run the real arithmetic. 1.01 to the power of 250 trading days is about 12, so $1,000 becomes roughly $12,000 in a year. Stretch it to two years and the multiple is about 145, near $145,000. Five years of it gives a multiple around a quarter of a million.
The sheet never mentions that the maths assumes a steady 1% every single day, no losing days, no bad weeks, and fills and liquidity that stay the same as the account grows.
Real results arrive in lumps. A 1% average with plenty of variance is a very different animal from 1% each day. The variance drags compounded growth below the simple average, and the path has deep dips the sheet skips.
A target is fine. A smooth curve sold as a plan is the gripe.
What daily or monthly figure would you call realistic for a scalper, and why that number?
stop posting those 1% a day spreadsheets
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 978
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: stop posting those 1% a day spreadsheets
1.01^250 is about 12 is the bit that should end the conversation. And that's before a single losing week. A month of minus 1 percent days takes away a lot more than most people think, since it has to be earned back from a lower base.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: stop posting those 1% a day spreadsheets
I fell for one of those sheets early on and it took a full year of honest record keeping to cure me. My actual equity curve that year was flat for weeks at a time, then jumped on a handful of good sessions, then gave a chunk back during one ugly fortnight in the summer. The average month looked respectable, but no single month looked like the average.
These days I think about it in risk units rather than percentages of the account. If I risk half a percent per trade and my edge is real, a good month for me is somewhere around four to eight risk units net, which works out to a few percent. Some months are negative, and I plan for that instead of pretending it will not happen.
The figure I would call realistic for most scalpers is the one that survives costs, slippage and a bad patch without forcing bigger size. If the target only works when every week is green, it is a wish rather than a plan.
These days I think about it in risk units rather than percentages of the account. If I risk half a percent per trade and my edge is real, a good month for me is somewhere around four to eight risk units net, which works out to a few percent. Some months are negative, and I plan for that instead of pretending it will not happen.
The figure I would call realistic for most scalpers is the one that survives costs, slippage and a bad patch without forcing bigger size. If the target only works when every week is green, it is a wish rather than a plan.