A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
A signal fires with EURUSD at 1.0852. You can buy at market, or put a buy limit at 1.0850 and save 2 pips. The stop is 1.0846 either way, the target 1.0861.
Market entry: risk 6, reward 9. Limit entry: risk 4, reward 11. That looks obviously better, but there's a catch in who gets filled.
Let's use 100 signals and make up round numbers. At market, 45 reach the target and 55 hit the stop, so the result is 45 times 9 minus 55 times 6, which is +75 pips before costs.
Every trade that hits the 1.0846 stop has to trade through 1.0850 on the way down, so the limit fills on all 55 losers. Winners are different: some run straight away and never pull back 2 pips. Suppose 20 of the 45 winners never touch 1.0850. The limit fills 25 winners at +11 and 55 losers at -4. That's 275 minus 220, which is +55 pips. Worse than the +75 at market, on fewer trades.
The break-even is the share of winners missed. Limit result is 45 times (1 - m) times 11 minus 220, and it equals 75 when m is 40.4%. If more than about 40% of your winners run without a pullback, the limit lowers the result.
The loser fill rate is 100% and the winner fill rate is lower. That's the selection problem, and the entry type alone won't remove it.
A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1693
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
Fairman, the limit order example captures adverse selection well: the fill comes mostly when price is moving against you. A way to measure it on your own data is to compare, for filled limit orders, how often the stop was hit against market entries taken on the same signals. If limit fills hit the stop noticeably more often, the 2 pips saved is being paid back elsewhere.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
Costs favour the limit slightly because fewer trades pay the spread. At 0.8 pips per trade, market entry pays 100 times 0.8, which is 80 pips and leaves -5 net. The limit with 20 winners missed makes 80 trades and pays 64, leaving 55 minus 64, which is -9 net. Both lose, the limit marginally more. If only 30% of winners are missed, the limit takes 31.5 winners at +11 and 55 losers at -4, which is 346.5 minus 220, or +126.5 gross on 86.5 trades, about +57 net. So the answer depends heavily on m, and m is something you can actually measure.
It’s Fairman 
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
Different improvements give different break-even rates. With the same 45% winners at 9 and 55% losers at 6, a limit 1 pip better only has to miss fewer than about 22% of winners to be equal. At 2 pips better it's about 40%, and at 3 pips better it's about 56%. A deeper limit has a bigger payoff when it fills, since it saves more on every loser and adds more to every winner, and it tolerates more misses. The cost is that it fills a smaller group more selectively, and a few of those are the trades that just keep going down. These all assume the stop sits below the limit price.
It’s Fairman 
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
Mixing the two splits the difference. Half the size at market and half on the limit, using the 100 signal example with 20 winners missed: the market half makes 37.5 pips and the limit half makes (275 minus 220) divided by 2, which is 27.5, for 65 pips total against 75 for all market. You give up 10 of the 75 pips, though the market half still catches the runners, and there are fewer days where nothing fills at all. Whether that's useful depends on whether missing a runner hurts you more than the lost pips.
It’s Fairman 
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
The mirror image is a stop entry, where you buy above the signal price on a break. Losers that never rise don't fill, so the order removes some bad trades, but it also fills on spikes that reverse. None of these entry types adds edge to a driftless market. They decide which trades you collect. To pick one for your signal, ask how winners behave in the first three minutes: if most pull back 2 pips before running, a limit is good, and if most run straight away, use market or a stop. Record the pullback depth of the first few minutes on 40 or 50 signals before you decide.
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: A limit order 2 pips better than market: why the fills you get are the worse ones
When a limit order fills during a fast move, the fill price can be better than requested. That's positive slippage. In practice, brokers rarely deliver it on take-profit orders.
The reason is the way the order is handled. A take-profit is a limit order resting on the server. When the bid touches it, the broker fills at the limit price. Even if the market gaps beyond the level, many systems fill at the limit rather than the better price.
Slippage on the stop side works the opposite way: the fill happens at the market price, which may be worse than the stop level.
The result is an asymmetry. Losses slip, profits don't. Over thousands of trades, the average outcome is a little worse than the theory predicted.
A test is to look at all take-profit fills and compare the fill price to the order price. If none, or almost none, are better than requested, even during fast conditions, the system is capping the upside.
Whether this is fair depends on the disclosure. Some brokers state it clearly, others don't mention it.
How often does a take-profit fill better than the set price? Any logs showing it?
The reason is the way the order is handled. A take-profit is a limit order resting on the server. When the bid touches it, the broker fills at the limit price. Even if the market gaps beyond the level, many systems fill at the limit rather than the better price.
Slippage on the stop side works the opposite way: the fill happens at the market price, which may be worse than the stop level.
The result is an asymmetry. Losses slip, profits don't. Over thousands of trades, the average outcome is a little worse than the theory predicted.
A test is to look at all take-profit fills and compare the fill price to the order price. If none, or almost none, are better than requested, even during fast conditions, the system is capping the upside.
Whether this is fair depends on the disclosure. Some brokers state it clearly, others don't mention it.
How often does a take-profit fill better than the set price? Any logs showing it?