Advertisement IC Markets

Monthly desk award: best process post not best P&L

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Monthly desk award: best process post not best P&L

Post by LondonScalper »

Monthly desk award: best process post, not best P&L

P&L screenshots teach the wrong lesson and invite the wrong competition. I would rather pin the post that shows a clean stand-aside, a cost log, an honest soft-breach reset, or a post-mortem that admits the rule break without theatre.

Idea for the forum: a monthly desk award for best process post — judged on clarity of rule, honesty about failure, and usefulness to other scalpers. Green equity curves optional and, frankly, suspicious as a ranking tool. It nudges culture toward survival skills instead of highlight reels.

I would happily lose a “PnL contest” every month if the process thread that wins helps someone keep their daily loss limit intact.

Would a “best process post” monthly award change what you bother writing — and what criteria should count?

Judging could be a small rotating panel of regulars using a simple scorecard: clarity, honesty, replicability. Keep P&L out of the scoring sheet entirely so the incentive stays clean.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Monthly desk award: best process post not best P&L

Post by Shadow Trader »

Count me in, with one change to the criteria. Judge posts that are at least a month old, and give a point only if the author came back and said whether they actually kept the rule.

Without that, the award goes to the best written rule, which isn't the same as the most useful one. Plenty of clean stand-aside posts are followed by the same person chasing CPI three weeks later.

For the scorecard I'd keep your three headings and score each 0 to 2, so the top mark is 6. Replicability is the easiest to test: could a reader apply the rule next Monday without asking a single question?

I'd also weight stand-aside posts the same as trade posts. A well explained skip of a CPI morning is harder to write honestly than a winner, and it's the behaviour the award is meant to reward.

The risk with a rotating panel is that regulars end up scoring each other. Maybe panel members sit out any month they've entered, or entries get judged with the username hidden.

The incentive problem from public journals applies here too. Would you limit it to one entry per person per month, so nobody starts writing process posts as content?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Monthly desk award: best process post not best P&L

Post by Shadow Trader »

LondonScalper, one thing I underrated in my first reply is how nominations reach the panel. If authors put their own posts forward, the award drifts toward people who enjoy writing, which is a different skill from keeping a rule.

I would make nominations come from readers only, and the nominator has to say which session they tried the rule in. Five tried sessions from any reader gets a post onto the shortlist, and the panel only scores that shortlist.

That also settles the hidden username idea, which I now think fails anyway. Regulars here recognise each other by phrasing within two lines, so blind judging would mostly be theatre.

A cap of five shortlisted posts and three panel members keeps the work small enough to survive past the third month. Most forum awards die from admin fatigue, not from bad criteria.

The last tweak I would add is a quiet runner up for the best losing month write up. Would you be comfortable with readers seeing which posts got tried and which only got praised?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Monthly desk award: best process post not best P&L

Post by Shadow Trader »

Trading advice often assumes that the London open and the New York overlap are the best times for everyone. Individual energy and focus vary, and so does performance.

A trader who works best in the early morning might find that late-session trades are sloppy. Someone who feels sluggish before ten may perform well in the afternoon. Local time zones also matter, since a 3am London open may mean being tired before the session even starts.

The data is available in the journal. Group trades by hour of the day, in local time, and compare average result, win rate, and the proportion that followed the rules. Most traders find a clear pattern.

Once identified, the schedule can adapt. Trading only the best two or three hours, and skipping the rest, often improves results without any change in strategy.

That can feel counterintuitive, since more screen time seems like more opportunity. But a tired mind loses money faster than a rested mind can make it.

Time zone shifts, travel, and changes in daylight saving also alter the pattern. Rechecking the hour-by-hour data after a change in schedule prevents old conclusions from persisting past their usefulness.

Which hours produce your best results, and do they match when you feel sharpest?
Post Reply