Advertisement IC Markets

Roundup: Logging your broker's spread by the clock, what the threads agree on

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Roundup: Logging your broker's spread by the clock, what the threads agree on

Post by Fairman »

Roundup: Logging your broker's spread by the clock, what the threads agree on

We've had a run of small threads on the board where people log spreads at fixed times instead of trusting the number on the broker's website. None of them got much traffic on its own, but read together they make a pretty complete method, so here's the short version in one place.

Why bother logging at all

The common thread is that "EURUSD is cheap" or "AUD is fine" is a feeling, and feelings are usually formed on a quiet Tuesday. The 07:00 EURUSD log thread makes the point well: one lucky morning turns into policy unless you have a number written down for lots of mornings. The marketing thread adds the vocabulary problem. "From 0.0" and "minimum" describe the best few seconds of the week, "typical" is vague about when it was measured, and only an average or median taken at your own hours is any use for planning.

How people are actually doing it
  • Fixed clock stamps. One thread samples 08:00, 13:00 and 15:00 London on the same ten weekdays for every account. Another watches AUDUSD around 13:30 because that's when that trader is actually active, not the open.
  • A small script on a VPS writing time, bid, ask and spread to CSV every few seconds for a month, then median and 95th percentile per hour.
  • A live spread readout on the chart that changes colour when the spread is a multiple of that pair's normal. Less data, but it stops you clicking in a hole.
  • All-in cost rather than raw spread: spread plus commission plus median slip on market orders, which is how the IC Markets hours thread built its "cheapest window" list.
Where they disagree

Average versus median is the live argument. One reply in the 07:00 thread dropped the average entirely, because spread data is skewed: most minutes sit near the floor and a single spike drags the mean around. The script thread reports both plus a high percentile, which seems like the sensible middle. My own lean is median for planning and the 95th percentile for deciding whether a window is dangerous.

The other disagreement is how often to re-check. One thread treats its hourly map as something to redo every quarter, the comparison sheet treats it as a one-off that decides where size goes. Spreads shift with seasons, liquidity providers and DST, so a one-off map goes stale quietly.

Caveats worth keeping

The comparison sheet found two raw accounts that looked identical at lunch but behaved very differently at 08:05. That's the whole argument for clock stamps in one line: brokers differ most at the moments scalpers care about. Also, a log taken on a quiet August week will flatter everything, and the IC thread noticed that even when spreads looked fine in mid-August, slippage on stops was ugly. Spread is one column, not the whole cost.

Last thing: the readout thread pointed out that the spread is part of your stop. A five pip stop with a one pip spread is already a fifth of the way to being hit. If you only take one habit from these threads, make it checking the live spread against your own baseline before the click.

If you log spreads, what times do you stamp, and did your numbers ever change which hours you trade?

Threads this pulls from
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1692
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Roundup: Logging your broker's spread by the clock, what the threads agree on

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

A small refinement to the logging method: record the spread at a fixed second as well as a fixed minute. Some brokers widen for a few seconds right on the minute around rollover or data, so a log taken at 07:00:00 and one at 07:00:30 can tell different stories.

It is also worth logging the same times on two brokers in parallel for a couple of weeks. Absolute numbers matter less than the gap between them at the hours you actually trade. That comparison is usually what decides whether moving accounts is worth the hassle.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Roundup: Logging your broker's spread by the clock, what the threads agree on

Post by Shadow Trader »

A trader exports the history and compares timestamps with the news release. The fills look to be a few seconds early or late relative to the event. Either the trade was lucky, or the clock was off.

Server clocks aren't always synced. Some brokers drift by a second or two. Others reflect a deliberate offset, such as GMT+2 or +3, and the difference between server time and local time is easy to miscalculate.

For scalping around news or fixings, the clock matters a lot. A one-second error turns "entered before the release" into "entered after the release," and the conclusions drawn from the data flip.

A decent check is comparing the platform's displayed server time with a reliable time source at a known moment. The difference is the offset, and it's worth noting.

The local computer's clock matters too. Operating systems sync with time servers intermittently, and a laptop that hasn't synced in a week can be a second or more off.

Anything involving timing analysis starts with confirming the clocks.

Has a clock error ever made a good trade look bad, or a bad trade look good?
Post Reply