Free SMC Trading Setups
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
Fair points, and the 10% risk thing needed saying. A 30% win rate means long losing streaks are normal, so size has to be small enough to sit through them. I like the fixed format idea too, I'll try to stick to pair, timeframe, entry, stop, target and whether there's news inside the holding window, and post the result either way.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
Had a read through the code. The order makes sense to me, impulse first, then the OB behind it, then sweep and FVG as filters. Couple of things I'd check on the chart: with UseBodyOnly off the OB zone gets pretty fat on big wick candles, so the stop line can end up miles away on gold. I'd also make sure Mitigated and Returned can't both flip on the same touch, otherwise the dash is telling you the same thing twice. If the OB lines on your screenshot sit on the last opposite candle before the impulse then yeah, it's doing what it should.
It’s Fairman 
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
Predicting vs reacting is the right way to put it. Fewer lines means when price gets to one you actually pay attention instead of shrugging. I'll have a look at the script, just make sure it isn't drawing every minor swing or we're back to twenty lines lol
It’s Fairman 
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
The classic news straddle places a buy stop above the market and a sell stop below it a few minutes before a big release. In theory, whichever way price breaks, one order catches the move. In practice, the idea fails often enough to deserve a closer look.
First, spreads widen before the release, so both orders may sit far from the live price and get filled at much worse levels than planned. Second, price often spikes in one direction, triggers one order, reverses violently, and triggers the other order, producing two losing trades. Third, slippage on stop orders during news can be huge, turning a planned five-pip risk into fifteen or twenty.
Brokers also behave differently. Some restrict pending orders near news, some widen minimum distances, and some reject orders entirely. A strategy tested in calm conditions can look completely different once these restrictions apply.
The data tends to reveal the problem quickly. Logging each news straddle with planned versus actual entry and exit prices for twenty events usually shows how much edge disappeared in execution.
If a straddle is still attractive, a more disciplined version places the orders after the first spike has passed, perhaps a minute or two after the release, targeting the second move rather than the first. This avoids the worst spread and slippage but gives up the early part of the move. Testing both versions on the same events gives a fair comparison, and the difference in execution cost is often larger than the difference in signal quality.
Has any version of a news straddle actually worked for you over a meaningful sample, and what made the difference?
First, spreads widen before the release, so both orders may sit far from the live price and get filled at much worse levels than planned. Second, price often spikes in one direction, triggers one order, reverses violently, and triggers the other order, producing two losing trades. Third, slippage on stop orders during news can be huge, turning a planned five-pip risk into fifteen or twenty.
Brokers also behave differently. Some restrict pending orders near news, some widen minimum distances, and some reject orders entirely. A strategy tested in calm conditions can look completely different once these restrictions apply.
The data tends to reveal the problem quickly. Logging each news straddle with planned versus actual entry and exit prices for twenty events usually shows how much edge disappeared in execution.
If a straddle is still attractive, a more disciplined version places the orders after the first spike has passed, perhaps a minute or two after the release, targeting the second move rather than the first. This avoids the worst spread and slippage but gives up the early part of the move. Testing both versions on the same events gives a fair comparison, and the difference in execution cost is often larger than the difference in signal quality.
Has any version of a news straddle actually worked for you over a meaningful sample, and what made the difference?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
Swap-free, or Islamic, accounts remove overnight interest charges. Some brokers offer them to clients with religious requirements, and some extend them more broadly.
For a scalper who never holds overnight, swap is irrelevant. But brokers usually replace swap with other charges: a fixed administration fee per day after a number of days, wider spreads, or extra commission. The label doesn't mean free.
The fine print varies. Some brokers apply the fee after three days, some immediately, and some only on certain instruments. A forgotten position on a swap-free account can accumulate charges that exceed the usual swap.
Eligibility rules also vary. Many require documentation and apply to specific account types.
Anyone using such an account should read the fee schedule and confirm the exact charges for positions held past the rollover.
Comparing total cost on a sample trade, a one-lot position held three days with the swap-free fee against the same position with normal swap, turns the vague label into a concrete number that is easy to weigh.
Does the account type include a hidden fee that would show up on a forgotten position?
For a scalper who never holds overnight, swap is irrelevant. But brokers usually replace swap with other charges: a fixed administration fee per day after a number of days, wider spreads, or extra commission. The label doesn't mean free.
The fine print varies. Some brokers apply the fee after three days, some immediately, and some only on certain instruments. A forgotten position on a swap-free account can accumulate charges that exceed the usual swap.
Eligibility rules also vary. Many require documentation and apply to specific account types.
Anyone using such an account should read the fee schedule and confirm the exact charges for positions held past the rollover.
Comparing total cost on a sample trade, a one-lot position held three days with the swap-free fee against the same position with normal swap, turns the vague label into a concrete number that is easy to weigh.
Does the account type include a hidden fee that would show up on a forgotten position?
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1693
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Free SMC Trading Setups
Silver this year has been a different animal, agreed. Trading only the long side from strong support is a sensible way to cut the decision tree in half. One thing to watch with the bigger stop: silver's point value differs a lot between brokers and contract sizes, so a stop that looks similar to a gold stop in dollars can be several times larger as a share of the account. Worth recalculating lot size from scratch for XAG rather than carrying over the gold habit, especially on days when the move per minute is twice what it was a year ago.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy